TWA Flight 5787

Trans World Airlines Flight 5787 was an unscheduled training flight of a Boeing 707 from Atlantic City Airport in Pomona, New Jersey in 1969. The flight was planned as a proficiency check, testing crew response to a simulated single engine failure during takeoff and landing. Because of a fatigue failure of a hydraulic pipe, hydraulic power was lost while flying at low speed on three engines, resulting in loss of control and a crash killing all on board.

TWA Flight 5787

TWA Boeing 707-331C N788TW sister-ship to the accident aircraft at LAX on August 16, 1964
Accident
Date	July 26, 1969
Summary	Loss of control due to hydraulic failure during simulated three-engined landing
Site	Atlantic City International Airport, NJ (ACY/KACY) 39°27′14″N 74°34′18.18″W
Aircraft
Aircraft type	Boeing 707-331C
Operator	Trans World Airlines
Registration	N787TW
Flight origin	John F. Kennedy Airport, Queens, NY (JFK/KJFK)
Stopover	Atlantic City Airport, Pomona, NJ (ACY/KACY)
Destination	John F. Kennedy Airport, Queens, NY (JFK/KJFK)
Passengers	0
Crew	5
Fatalities	5
Survivors	0

Aircraft and crew

The aircraft involved was a Boeing 707-331C (registration number N787TW), first flown in 1964. The aircraft had 17,590 flight hours at the time of the accident.[1][2]^:8

The crew, and sole occupants, were instructor pilot Harry D. Gaines (56), two captains, first officer Donald Sklarin (38), and flight engineer Frank J. Jonke (29).[2]^:7–8

Accident

On July 26, 1969, Trans World Airlines (TWA) aircraft N787TW arrived at John F. Kennedy Airport at the end of a scheduled cargo flight. The aircraft was then released for non-revenue training use as Flight 5787, providing recurrent training and proficiency checks for three TWA line captains. Flight 5787 originated at JFK, and was planned to proceed to the National Aviation Facilities Experimental Center (NAFEC) at Atlantic City Airport to perform the required training and proficiency check maneuvers.[2]^:1

After take-off from JFK, Flight 5787 proceeded to Atlantic City Airport without incident. On arrival, the aircraft landed on runway 13 with the first check-ride Captain Gaines at the controls, in the left-hand seat. The crew requested a 180° turnaround and an immediate take-off on runway 31, which was granted. The proficiency checker briefed the take-off as a simulated engine failure after V₁. The take-off was carried out and the No. 4 power lever was retarded to the simulated failure idle position. The pilots climbed to 1,500 ft (457 m) and vectored to intercept the ILS course at the outer marker. The tower granted Flight 5787 permission to either land, make a touch-and-go landing, or make a low approach of the runway at its discretion.[1][2]^:4

The proficiency checker briefed the check pilot to carry out a three-engine ILS approach and expect a three engine go-around at the decision height. The proficiency checker called for the go-around at the decision height, and the check captain complied, applying full power on engine nos. 1, 2, and 3, leaving engine no. 4 at idle, then calling for flaps 25 and landing gear up. However, neither the flaps nor landing gear moved from their previous positions.[2]^:4 Approximately 16 to 18 seconds after the call for go-around, one of the observing crew commented that all hydraulic power had been lost. In accordance with the current operating procedures, the hydraulic pumps were disengaged. The crew did not call for or follow the hydraulic fluid loss checklist.[2]^:5

With low airspeed, 3 engines, and no hydraulics to power the rudder actuator, directional control was lost. The aircraft rolled and pitched down, impacting the ground in a right wing low nose down attitude. All five crew were killed.[1][2]^:5–6

Causes

The cause of the accident was found to be poor procedures for simulating engine failures and failure to apply the correct procedure for hydraulic failure, as well as loss of hydraulic power to the rudder in a critical flight condition. The loss of hydraulic power was found to be due to a fatigue failure in the left outboard spoiler actuator downline, dumping hydraulic fluid from the aircraft's utility hydraulic system overboard. With no power to the rudder actuator, at low speed, undercarriage down, full flaps and only three engines, the aircraft was not capable of recovery and the crash was inevitable.[1][2]

Consequences

Procedures for hydraulic failure and simulating engine failures were reviewed and amended as deemed necessary.

References

1. "TW5787". ASN. Retrieved January 18, 2020.
2. "Trans World Airlines, Inc., Boeing 707-331C, N787TW, National Aviation Facilities Experimental Center, Atlantic city Airport, Pomona, New Jersey, July 26, 1969" (PDF). ntsb.gov. National Transportation Safety Board. March 25, 1970. File No.1-0017. Retrieved January 18, 2020.