None of These Candidates
None of These Candidates is a voting option in Nevada for all state and federal election ballots. This option is listed along with the names of individuals running for the position and is often described as "none of the above". The option first appeared on the Nevada ballot in 1975.[1]
| Elections in Nevada |
|---|
 |
| None of These Candidates |
In the event that the "None of These Candidates" option receives the most votes in an election, the actual candidate who receives the most votes still wins the election. This has most notably happened on two occasions: in the 1976 Republican primary for Nevada's At-large congressional district, None of These Candidates received 16,097 votes, while Walden Earhart won 9,831 votes, followed by Dart Anthony with 8,097 votes. Even though he received fewer votes than "None of These Candidates", Earhart received the Republican nomination.[1] He went on to lose to incumbent Democratic Congressman Jim Santini in the general election. In the 2014 Democratic gubernatorial primary, "None of These Candidates" won 30% of the popular vote, a plurality. Robert Goodman, the runner-up with 25% of the vote, was the Democratic nominee by state law.[2]
Notable impact on elections
According to a report by then-Secretary of State Dean Heller, "None of These Candidates" has finished first on three other occasions: in a 1978 Republican congressional primary, a 1978 Republican Secretary of State primary and a 1986 Democratic Treasurer primary. Additionally, it happened again in the 2014 Democratic gubernatorial primary making it a grand total of five instances.[3]
The "None of These Candidates" option has possibly played a spoiler effect in close races, such as in the 1998 U.S. Senate election, in which Democratic incumbent Sen. Harry Reid defeated Republican challenger John Ensign by only 428 votes, while None of These Candidates drew 8,125 votes.[4]
Court challenge
In June 2012, anticipating a close race in Nevada during the 2012 presidential elections, the Republican National Committee challenged the constitutionality of the option. Fearing that the option would siphon votes from the Republican nominee, the RNC claimed that the option is not constitutional because if "None of these Candidates" received the most votes, it would not win the election.
The Nevada Attorney General, on behalf of the Secretary of State of Nevada, argued that the option is a protest vote intended to send a message and whose outcome is no different from not voting at all. On August 22, U.S. District Court Judge Robert Jones agreed with the plaintiffs and struck down the law allowing the option as unconstitutional. He refused to issue a stay pending the outcome of an appeal, meaning the ban on this option would be immediate.[5]
On September 4, the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit issued an emergency stay against the district court's order.[6] The emergency stay barred the implementation of Judge Jones's injunction until the Ninth Circuit could hear an appeal, allowing the "none of these candidates" option to remain on the ballot in the November 2012 elections. On July 10, 2013, the Court of Appeals threw out the lawsuit, preserving the "none of these candidates" option.[7] One member of that panel, Judge Stephen Reinhardt, criticized Jones' handling of the case: "His dilatory tactics appear to serve no purpose other than to seek to prevent the state from taking an appeal of his decision before it prints the ballots.... Such arrogance and assumption of power by one individual is not acceptable in our judicial system."[8]
Results in statewide elections
U.S. Presidential elections results in Nevada
- 1976: 5,108 votes (2.53%)
- 1980: 4,193 votes (1.69%)
- 1984: 3,950 votes (1.38%)
- 1988: 6,934 votes (1.98%)
- 1992: 2,537 votes (0.50%)
- 1996: 5,608 votes (1.21%)
- 2000: 3,315 votes (0.54%)
- 2004: 3,668 votes (0.44%)
- 2008: 6,267 votes (0.65%)
- 2012: 5,770 votes (0.57%)
- 2016: 28,863 votes (2.56%, a little more than the margin of victory which was 27,202 votes)
- 2020: 14,079 votes (1.00%)
U.S. Senate elections
- 1992: 13,154 votes (2.65%)
- 1994: 12,626 votes (3.32%)
- 1998: 8,125 votes (1.86%, almost 19 times the margin of victory, which was 428 votes)
- 2000: 11,503 votes (1.92%)
- 2004: 12,968 votes (1.60%)
- 2006: 8,232 votes (1.41%)
- 2010: 16,197 votes (2.25%)
- 2012: 45,277 votes (4.54%, almost four times the margin of victory, which was 11,576 votes)
- 2016: 42,257 votes (3.81%, about 57% higher than the margin of victory, which was 26,915 votes)
- 2018: 15,303 votes (1.57%)
References
- Silver, Nate (2010-08-27). "In Nevada, No One Is Someone to Watch - NYTimes.com". Fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com. Retrieved 2010-08-27.
- Smith, Alexander (11 June 2014). "Nevada Democrats Chose 'None of These Candidates' in Primary". NBC News. Retrieved 3 November 2020.
- Sean Whaley (June 11, 2014). "'None of the above' beats out all Demo governor candidates in Nevada". Las Vegas Review-Journal. Retrieved July 17, 2014.
- "None of These Candidates". Onlinenevada.org. 2009-08-26. Retrieved 2010-08-27.
- "Federal judge strikes down Nevada's "none of the above" voting option". Washington Post. Associated Press. August 22, 2012. Archived from the original on August 10, 2019. Retrieved September 6, 2017.
- "Emergency Stay Order, Townley v. Miller" (PDF). United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit. September 4, 2012.
- Chereb, Sandra (July 10, 2013). "'None Of The Above' Ballot Option In Nevada Upheld By Federal Appeals Court". Huffington Post. Archived from the original on November 25, 2015.
- "Nevadans to keep "none of the above" ballot option". CBS News. September 5, 2012. Archived from the original on September 8, 2012. Retrieved November 30, 2012.
Notes
- Values given are for the general election. During the Democratic primary, the "None of These candidates" received more votes than any actual candidate. Since only actual candidates can win, Bob Goodman, the candidate with the most votes, won the primary and advanced to the general election.