Howard S. McDonald

Howard Stevenson McDonald (July 18, 1894 – October 25, 1986) was President of Brigham Young University (BYU) from 1945 to 1949. During his presidency, the board of trustees approved a master of theology program. Enrollment at BYU greatly increased after World War II, and McDonald petitioned the board of trustees to build many buildings, including the Eyring Science Center. McDonald helped establish the student health center and student wards. He discouraged students from smoking and drinking. He left BYU because of his strained relationship with the board of trustees.

Howard S. McDonald
McDonald pictured in The Banyan 1946, BYU yearbook
President of Brigham Young University
In office July 1945 – October 1949[1]
Preceded by	Franklin S. Harris
Succeeded by	Ernest L. Wilkinson
Personal details
Born	July 18, 1894 Holladay, Utah
Died	October 25, 1986 (aged 92) Los Alamitos, California

McDonald was president of Los Angeles State College (now known as California State University, Los Angeles) and Los Angeles City College in 1949. In 1958, Los Angeles City College received its own president as a junior college. McDonald helped found San Fernando State College (now known as California State University, Northridge) in 1956, and was president of the general faculty until 1958. He helped to formally organize the colleges, recruit more faculty, build more buildings, and petition the state of California for funds.

Early life and education

The Howard S. McDonald building at Brigham Young University

McDonald was born in Holladay, Utah[2] on July 18, 1894, to Francis McDonald and Rozella Stevenson. He attended the first LDS Seminary, the Granite High School Seminary.[3]^:419 He served as a missionary in The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints (LDS Church) in the Eastern States Mission, which was headquartered in New York City. He spent part of his mission as president of the Western Pennsylvania Conference headquartered in Pittsburgh. While serving in this area he met Ella Gibbs, a woman serving as a missionary who was the first Relief Society president in Pittsburgh. Ella was later transferred to Baltimore. After both returned from their missions, McDonald courted Ella Gibbs. They married in the Salt Lake Temple on September 26, 1917. They had two daughters.[4][5]

In 1918, McDonald served in the 163rd Artillery Brigade in France.[6]^:27 Following his military service, he graduated from Utah State Agricultural College in 1924 in architectural engineering. He taught advanced mathematics at Utah State Agricultural College during the chairman's sabbatical.[6]^:36

Teaching career

Franklin Harris asked him to head BYU's engineering department in 1924, but McDonald declined, stating that he was unqualified for the position. He taught math and physical education part-time at Mission High School while studying at the University of California, Berkeley. He received his M.A. from there in 1925.[2][3]^:420–422 In 1928 he was vice-principal and dean of boys at Balboa High School, and 1934–1936 he was director of personnel in the San Francisco School District,[3]^:422–423 becoming superintendent in 1937.[6]^:46 From 1944–45, McDonald was superintendent of schools in Salt Lake City, Utah.[2] He instituted the 12-year system and successfully campaigned for better funding for public schools.[3]^:424 In 1949 he completed a Doctorate of Education, also from the University of California.[1][6]^:100

President of BYU

Importance of religious studies

McDonald became president of Brigham Young University in 1945. At McDonald's request, he had meetings directly with the board of trustees, not receiving their instructions through a commissioner of church schools. Unlike with his previous administrative roles, the board of trustees wanted more input over the details of administration compared to the boards of public school districts, who were happy to defer administrative details to McDonald.[3]^:427–428 Additionally, the board selected McDonald as president because they believed McDonald could bring a stronger religious emphasis to the school with his ecclesiastical leadership background.[7] Initially the board of trustees asked McDonald to prepare to close BYU, but McDonald convinced them of the LDS Church's need for BYU. Joseph Fielding Smith was particularly concerned with the education of institute teachers, which he felt was best done at a church-owned institution.[1]

Religious studies at BYU were a great source for seminary instruction materials and training for seminary teachers. However, religious instructors had previously focused on encouraging students to live righteous lives rather than on intellectually engaging with religious ideas. John A. Widtsoe advised against forming a graduate school separate from the rest of BYU, stating there were fears that an overly scholarly school of divinity could create unorthodox graduates. In 1949, the board of trustees approved a master of theology degree and encouraged graduates to study elsewhere for their doctorate.[3]^:450–455

Sudden increase in enrollment

Enrollment more than doubled in the winter and fall semesters as veterans from World War II came home and enrolled at BYU. His administration received surplus military buildings from the Federal Public Housing Authority in San Francisco to house the huge influx of students, and they began to build permanent buildings to replace them.[1] McDonald initiated the construction of several new buildings to alleviate the intense crowding at the university. He petitioned the board of trustees for approval to build a large science building, partially planned by Dean Eyring. The planned building was larger than the five largest buildings on campus combined. While some members of the board disliked the proposal, Joseph Fielding Smith championed the project. In 1945, the projected cost was around $300,000, and the board approved a budget of $950,000. The final cost of the Eyring Science Center was over 2 million dollars.[3]^:437–439 Enrollment in the College of Arts and Sciences increased five percent.[3]^:460 Construction on other buildings was suspended because of the high cost of the science building, and in 1947 several physical education instructors resigned because of "unfavorable working conditions," and the board of trustees considered abandoning sports programs altogether. Other in-progress building projects were heavily delayed.[3]^:444 The board of trustees approved plans for the Smith Fieldhouse, which was completed in 1951.[3]^{:484; 492}

Instructors at the time often taught over thirteen hours per week.[3]^:443 McDonald recruited more professors to teach the more numerous student body, including Hugh Nibley and M. Wells Jakeman. He petitioned to increase professors' salaries to make positions more attractive, and over 80 professors were hired during his administration.[3]^{:440; 484} He created a dean of student life position to organize student services, and gave more responsibility to department chairs, college deans, and their assistants, who conveyed faculty requests and ideas to him.[3]^:482–484

Ernest Wilkinson suggested that BYU increase the cost of tuition, and McDonald agreed with the idea, but stated that the First Presidency did not wish to burden students with more expensive tuition, despite their anxiety about the LDS Church's increased cost in enrolling so many more students. The cost to educate each student increased by $55 from 1944 to 1946, and faculty requested and received raises to combat postwar inflation.[3]^:445–448

Changes to student life

In 1946, McDonald organized a student health plan with Vasco Tanner as the chair on the committee. Full-time doctors were employed through a $10 contribution from each student.[3]^:466 The student health center was named after him.[8] He developed a character recommendation required for new applicants to the university to be sure that university attendees conform to the standards of the LDS Church.[7] Also in 1946, McDonald made efforts to stop students from smoking and drinking. He gave students three months to change their habits. He also called for more strict adherence to curfew. In Amanda Knight Hall, doors were locked on the outside and inside after curfew, causing one woman to publicly protest the policy as dangerous in the case of an emergency.[9] In 1947, McDonald helped establish student branches, with student leaders. This helped create a more intimate atmosphere for church services, as previous Sunday school classes could exceed 100 students at a time.[3]^:470–472

Leaving BYU

McDonald constantly requested additional funding, including emotional appeals, which strained his relationship with the board of trustees. J. Reuben Clark, then a counselor in the first presidency, was also unhappy with McDonald's performance as president of BYU and harshly rebuked his behavior; as tension grew McDonald began looking for another job. In 1949, McDonald left BYU to become president of Los Angeles City College and Los Angeles State College.[1]

Educational administrator in California

When McDonald became president of both Los Angeles City College and Los Angeles State College, they were housed in borrowed spaces with part-time faculty. He hired administrators to help him formally organize the colleges. He found a site within LA[10] to house the new Los Angeles State College of Applied Arts and Sciences, which replaced the Los Angeles State College in 1949.[11] He recruited faculty, petitioned the California state government for more funds, and met with the state architect to plan buildings.[10] The college opened in its new location in 1958.[12] When McDonald retired in 1962, seven buildings on the new campus were completed.[10] The Los Angeles City College remained as a junior college under John Lombardi in 1958.[6]^:75

College students in California began to protest the loyalty oaths that faculty in California state colleges were compelled to make in 1950. After prohibiting the student executive council at the Los Angeles State College of Applied Arts and Sciences from discussing the issue, they resigned in protest. After negotiations, McDonald rescinded the ban on discussing the loyalty oaths and the student executive council returned.[13]

He helped found San Fernando Valley State College in 1956,[14] where he was president of the general faculty 1956–1958.[15] He retired in 1962 and was appointed as a regional representative of the US Commissioner of Education, a position he held until 1964.[16]

LDS Church service

McDonald served as a member of the San Francisco stake high council, a member of the stake presidency, and as stake president. In 1943, McDonald asked to be released as stake president so he could continue pursuing his doctoral studies.[3]^:421–422

Fifteen years after leaving as BYU president, he returned to Utah and served as president of the LDS Church's Salt Lake Temple from 1964 to 1968.[17]

References

1. Bergera, Gary James; Priddis, Ronald (1985). "Chapter 1: Growth & Development". Brigham Young University: A House of Faith. Salt Lake City: Signature Books. ISBN 0-941214-34-6. OCLC 12963965.
2. "Howard S. McDonald, ca. 1945". BYU Campus Photographs. Harold B. Lee Library, Brigham Young University. Archived from the original on 2011-06-12. Retrieved 2009-06-02.
3. Wilkinson, Ernest L., ed. (1975). Brigham Young University : the first one hundred years. 2. Provo, Utah: Brigham Young University Press. pp. 418–455. ISBN 0842507086.
4. Wilkinson, Ernest L., ed. (1975). Brigham Young University: the first one hundred years. 4. Provo, Utah: Brigham Young University Press. p. 463. ISBN 0842507086.
5. "LDS Scene". Ensign: 79–80. February 1987. Retrieved 2009-06-02.
6. McDonald, Howard S. (1969). Brief Autobiography. self-published.
7. Daines, J. Gordon (2020). ""By Study and Also by Faith": Balancing the Sacred and the Secular at Brigham Young University in the 1930s and 1940s". BYU Studies Quarterly. 59 (1). Retrieved 30 April 2020.
8. Winters, Charlene Renberg. "Moving The University Onward - BYU Magazine". BYU Magazine.
9. Bergera, Gary James; Priddis, Ronald (1985). "Chapter 3: Standards; the Honor Code". Brigham Young University: A House of Faith. Salt Lake City: Signature Books. ISBN 0-941214-34-6. OCLC 12963965.
10. Lloyd, William E. (4 November 2016). "In Memoriam". California State University, Los Angeles. Cal State LA. Retrieved 5 April 2018.
11. McDonald, Howard S. (1955). "Los Angeles State College of Applied Arts and Sciences--Unique in American Higher Education". In Simpson, Roy E. (ed.). The California State Colleges. Sacramento: California State Department of Education. pp. 139–150.
12. "Presidential History". California State University, Los Angeles. Cal State LA. 13 January 2014. Retrieved 5 April 2018.
13. Schwartz, Eugene G. (2006). American students organize: founding the National Student Association after World War II : an anthology and sourcebook. Washington, DC: American Council of Education. p. 1033. ISBN 9780275991005.
14. "Groundbreaking for Los Angeles State College, San Fernando Valley Campus (now CSUN), January 1956 :: CSUN University Archives". digital-library.csun.edu.
15. "Dr. Howard McDonald, ca. 1957". Calisphere. CSUN University Archives. Retrieved 5 April 2018.
16. Buchanan, Frederick S. (1996). Culture clash and accommodation : public schooling in Salt Lake City, 1890-1994. San Francisco: Smith Research Associates in association with Signature Books. ISBN 1560850825.
17. Buchanan, Frederick S. (1996). Culture Clash and Accommodation: Public Schooling in Salt Lake City, 1890-1994. Smith Research Associates. ISBN 1-56085-082-5.

External links

• Howard S. McDonald presidential papers, UA 1087 at L. Tom Perry Special Collections, Harold B. Lee Library, Brigham Young University
• Howard S. McDonald letters, MSS SC 1316 at L. Tom Perry Special Collections, Harold B. Lee Library, Brigham Young University