Honor killing in the United States

Several honor killings have been documented in the United States in recent years. As of 2012 there is no central agency that collects data across all jurisdictions in regards to honor violence in the United States. There is reluctance among some organizations to label events as honor killings to avoid stigmatizing Muslim and Arab cultures.[1]

Circa 2017 City University of New York John Jay College College of Criminal Justice professor Ric Curtis lead a team that analyzed honor killing statistics from Germany, the Netherlands, and the United Kingdom and made a proxy estimate for the United States based on that, resulting in an estimated 23-27 annual honor killings in the U.S. In 2017 Jesse Singal of New York Magazine wrote "there’s effectively no evidence that honor killings are common at all, according to one of the only (if not the only) studies attempting to estimate how prevalent that crime is."[2] Executive Order 13769 "Protecting the Nation from Foreign Terrorist Entry into the United States" stated that the U.S. federal government would collect information on honor killings committed by foreigners resident in the U.S.; Singal stated that the lack of prevalance of honor crimes in the U.S. "makes the language of Trump’s EO odd".[2]

In 2015 senior fellow of Center for Advanced Studies on Terrorism Farhana Qazi stated that the actual number of honor killings was higher than the reported statistics due to a reluctance to embarrass relatives of the deceased.[3] In 2012 Zuhdi Jasser of the think tank American Islamic Forum for Democracy argued that honor killings were a phenomenon in the U.S. that need to be investigated.[4]

Instances

Palestina Isa

In 1989 in St. Louis, Missouri, sixteen-year-old Palestina (Tina) Isa was murdered by her Palestinian father, Zein Isa, with the aid of her Brazilian mother, Maria Isa. Their daughter listened to American popular music such as dance, rap, R&B, and rock. After learning that Palestina had taken a part-time job without her parents' permission, and dated an African American man, her father felt she had become too modernized. On the day of her murder, Zein repeatedly stabbed his daughter Tina, while her mother Maria held her down.[5] On December 20, 1991[6] both Zein and Maria Isa were convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to death. He later died of diabetes complications on February 17, 1997. Maria's death sentence was commuted to life imprisonment without parole; she died on April 30, 2014, in a Vandalia, Missouri, prison at the age of 70.[7]

Amina and Sarah Said

Amina and Sarah Said were the children of Egyptian immigrant Yaser Abdel Said and American Patricia "Tissie" Owens. Both girls were born in Dallas, Texas, Amina on March 2, 1989, and Sarah on March 16, 1990. The girls were found shot to death in a taxi at the Omni Mandalay Hotel in Irving, Texas, on January 1, 2008. Both girls had left their home in Lewisville, Texas, earlier that evening, with their father Yaser Said. At 7:33 pm CT a call came into the Irving Police Department's 911 call center. The call was from Sarah Said. She had been shot nine times and told the operator, "My dad shot me and my sister. I'm dying!" Their mother, Patricia Said, claims that both girls were killed for having non-Muslim boyfriends. Death threats had been made by Yaser against the girls. They ran away and were safe, but their mother brought them back. Yaser Said was an FBI Top Ten Fugitive until his capture in 2020, the FBI was offering a $100,000[8] reward for information leading to his arrest.[9][10] Said has been featured on America's Most Wanted as well as on a Fox News special about honor killings in America;[11] he was also on the FBI's Ten Most Wanted List.

Yaser Abdel Said was captured on August 26, 2020, aged 63. He had been on the run for over twelve years up until then.[12]

Sandeela Kanwal

In July 2008, New York Post writer John P. Avlon claimed that the murder of 25-year-old Sandeela Kanwal—by her father, Chaudhry Rashid—was an "American Honor Killing."[13] Rashid strangled Kanwal to death with a bungee cord after she tried to end her arranged marriage. Chaudhry Rashid was then sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole.

Aasiya Zubair

In February 2009, Muzzammil Hassan was arrested and charged with murdering his estranged wife Aasiya Zubair with a knife and sentenced to 25 years to life in prison.

The Council on American-Islamic Relations and the Islamic Society of North America responded with an "Open Letter to Muslim Leaders", expressing shock and sadness at the murder, condemning domestic violence, and calling on imams and Muslim leaders to "provide support and help to protect the victims of domestic violence" and "to never second-guess a woman who comes to us indicating that she feels her life to be in danger."[14] Imam Mohamed Hagmagid Ali, vice-president of ISNA, stated: "This is a wake up call to all of us, that violence against women is real and cannot be ignored. It must be addressed collectively by every member of our community."[15]

Noor Almaleki

Faleh Hassan Almaleki, an Iraqi immigrant, used his vehicle to strike and kill his daughter Noor Almaleki (aged 20) in a Phoenix valley parking lot in October 2009; he also severely injured her boyfriend's mother, Amal Khalaf. Police said Almaleki told detectives and witnesses after the October 2009 incident that he was angry at his daughter because she was "too Westernized," defying Iraqi and Muslim values. Noor had shunned an arranged marriage to a first cousin in Iraq, and was living with her boyfriend and his mother, police said. Earlier, she had insisted on driving and crashed the family van. County prosecutor Laura Reckart said an enraged Almaleki hid in the parking lot waiting for her and her boyfriend's mother and then "revved and raced that car right into them." Following his daughter's death, Almaleki fled to Mexico and later to London, where he was taken into custody upon his arrival.[16]

After four days of deliberation, the six-man, six-woman jury at Maricopa County Superior Court convicted him of second-degree murder. The jury also convicted him of aggravated assault for crashing his vehicle into Khalaf, and two further counts of hit and run. Subsequently, Almaleki was sentenced to 34 ½ years in prison.[17]

Gelareh Bagherzadeh and Coty Beavers

Jordanian-American Ali Mahmood Awad Irsan was sentenced to death in a Texas court on August 14, 2018 for the murders of Gelareh Bagherzadeh and Coty Beavers in Greater Houston.[18] Bagherzadeh, an Iranian-American, had encouraged Irsan's daughter Nesreen to renounce Islam and to convert to Evangelical Christianity. Coty Beavers, who was also an Evangelical Christian,[19] was Nesreen's husband.[20]

American Muslim community response

Leaders of the American Muslim community have condemned the practice. Members of the Council on American-Islamic Relations have condemned all honor killings as well as specific incidents.[21] Many Muslim leaders in the US say that Islam does not promote honor killings and that the practice stems from sexism and tribal behavior that predates the religion. "You're always going to get problems with chauvinism and suppressing vulnerable populations and gender discrimination," says Salam Al-Marayati, executive director of the Muslim Public Affairs Council.[22]

In February 2009, after the high-profile killing of Aasiya Zubair, Muslim leaders began a nationwide, unified effort entitled "Imams Speak Out: Domestic Violence Will Not Be Tolerated in Our Communities," asking all imams and religious leaders to discuss domestic violence in their weekly sermon or their Friday prayer services.[23] The group, "Muslim Men Against Domestic Violence",[24] was founded soon after the murder.

See also

• Namus
• Outline of domestic violence

References

1. Dahl, Julia (2012-04-05). ""Honor killing" under growing scrutiny in the U.S." CBS News. Retrieved 2019-12-06. And if international data is bad,[...] state agency attempts to collect data on any kind of "honor" violence, including murders.[...]But the very notion that violence in the name of [...] and anti-Muslim sentiment.
2. Singal, Jesse (2017-03-06). "Here's What the Research Says About Honor Killings in the U.S." New York Magazine. Retrieved 2019-12-06.
3. McKay, Hollie (2015-11-10). "Honor killing in America: DOJ report says growing problem is hidden in stats". Fox News. Retrieved 2020-01-21.
4. Jasser, Zuhdi (2012-03-05). "Muslim women face threat in U.S." USA Today. Retrieved 2019-12-06.
5. Smith, Erika Lyn. "Tina Isa America's Honor Killing". Bella Online. Retrieved 2010-09-02.
6. "Missouri Couple Sentenced to Die In Murder of Their Daughter, 16". The New York Times. December 20, 1991.
7. "Woman convicted of killing her daughter dies in prison". FOX2now.com.
8. "FBI—New Top Ten Fugitive: Help Us Find a Murderer". FBI. Archived from the original on 2016-03-05.
9. Whitley, Glenna (June 19, 2008). "American Girls". Dallas Observer.
10. "Reward offered for Lewisville cabbie wanted in daughters' deaths". dallasnews.com.
11. "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2010-02-17. Retrieved 2010-10-26.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
12. "Father on FBI's most wanted list captured". BBC News. 27 August 2020. Retrieved 2 September 2020.
13. Avalon, John P. (July 23, 2008). "An American 'Honor Killing'". The New York Post.
14. "Prelude to Murder". The Daily Beast.
15. "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2011-11-03. Retrieved 2011-11-05.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
16. "Jury Convicts Iraqi Immigrant in 'Honor Killing' of Daughter". aolnews.com. Archived from the original on 2011-09-21.
17. "Iraqi guilty of murder in daughter's honor killing". Reuters.
18. Rogers, Brian (2018-08-14). "Jury delivers death sentence for Jordanian immigrant convicted of two Houston-area 'honor killings'". Houston Chronicle. Retrieved 2018-09-09.
19. Rogers, Brian (2018-06-18). "Wife testifies her husband confessed to pulling the trigger in one of two Houston-area 'honor killings'". Houston Chronicle. Retrieved 2018-09-09.
20. Malislow, Craig (2015-06-02). "Authorities Say Ali Irsan Stole Out of Greed and Murdered Out of Honor". Houston Press. Retrieved 2018-09-09.
21. "FOX-News: CAIR Condemns Domestic Violence Incident". YouTube.
22. "'Honor killings' in USA raise concerns - USATODAY.com". usatoday.com.
23. "American Muslims Call to Action to End Domestic Violence". startribune.com.
24. "Muslim Men Against Domestic Abuse". mmada.org.