Excellent Women

Excellent Women is a novel by Barbara Pym, first published in 1952, her second published novel[1] and generally acclaimed as the funniest and most successful of her comedies of manners.[2][3]

Excellent Women

First edition
Author	Barbara Pym
Country	United Kingdom
Language	English
Publisher	Jonathan Cape
Publication date	1952
Media type	Print (Hardback)
Pages	256 p. (hardback edition)

Title

The phrase "excellent women" is used by men[3] as a condescending reference to the kind of women who perform menial duties in the service of churches and voluntary organisations. The phrase was first used by Pym in her early unpublished novel Civil to Strangers and is taken from Jane Austen's novel Sanditon.[4]

Plot summary

The book details the everyday life of its narrator, Mildred Lathbury,[3] a spinster in her thirties in 1950s Britain. Perpetually self-deprecating, but with the sharpest wit, Mildred is a part-time voluntary worker who occupies herself by attending and helping at the local church.[5] Mildred's life grows more exciting with the arrival of new neighbours, anthropologist Helena Napier and her handsome, dashing husband, Rocky - with whom Mildred fancies herself in love. Through the Napiers, she meets another anthropologist, Everard Bone, and it is with him that Mildred will eventually form a relationship. A sub-plot revolves around the activities of the local vicar, Julian Malory, who becomes engaged to a glamorous widow, Allegra Gray. Allegra proceeds to ease out Julian's sister, Winifred, a close friend of Mildred's.[6] Eventually matters come to a head and Allegra leaves the vicarage after a quarrel. In the meantime, Helena, who has been on the verge of leaving Rocky for Everard, accepts that Everard does not care for her and leaves the neighbourhood, along with Rocky.

The novel concludes with Mildred unsure of her future, but having arranged to carry out indexing tasks for Everard Bone. Other Pym novels portray Everard and Mildred as a married couple, usually unseen.[7][8]

As with most of Pym's books, the plot is less important than the precise drawing of the comic characters (such as Everard's elderly mother who is obsessed with the suppression of woodworm) and situations.

Characters

• Mildred Lathbury
• Helena Napier
• Rockingham Napier
• Julian Malory
• Winifred Malory
• Everard Bone
• Mrs Bone
• Allegra Gray
• Dora Caldicote (Mildred's old schoolfriend)
• William Caldicote (Dora's brother)
• Mrs Morris (cleaning lady and confidante)
• Miss Jessop (friend of Mrs Bone)
• Sister Blatt (member of Julian's congregation)
• Other anthropologists

Publication history

Pym completed the novel in February 1951, and it was published by Jonathan Cape in 1952. The book was well-received and has remained one of her greatest successes. The Church Times compared Pym's writing to Jane Austen while John Betjeman reviewed the novel for The Daily Telegraph, writing that "Barbara Pym is a splendidly humorous writer".[9] The novel sold 6,577 copies in Great Britain by the end of the 1950s, far outselling her other early novels, although by no means a bestseller.[10]

By 1954, Pym wrote that eight American publishers and 10 publishers from Continental Europe had seen the manuscript and declined to publish it. Excellent Women was first published in the United States by E.P. Dutton in 1978. The novelist John Updike, reviewing the American release in 1978, wrote that:[11]

Excellent Women... is a startling reminder that solitude may be chosen, and that a lively, full novel can be constructed entirely within the precincts of that regressive virtue: feminine patience.

The novel was eventually published in France in 1990 as Des Femmes Remarquables, in Spain as Mujeres excelentes, in Italy as Donne eccellenti, and Germany as Vortreffliche Frauen. In 2011, Hachette released the novel as an audiobook read by Jonathan Keeble and Gerry Halligan.

Analysis

The novel has been noted for its accurate analysis of life in post-war England, where rationing was still in effect and everyone had suffered loss of people close to them.[12]

Pym drew on her own life for some elements of the novel. It is the first of many of her novels to feature anthropologists; Pym had worked at the International African Institute in London since 1946. The character of Rockingham Napier has been flag lieutenant to an admiral in Italy where his wife says he 'hasn't had to do anything much but be charming to a lot of dreary Wren officers'; Barbara Pym had been a WRN officer in Italy during World War II.

In a 14 July 1964 letter, having just re-read Excellent Women, the poet Philip Larkin wrote to Pym saying that the novel was "better than I remembered it, full of a harsh kind of suffering [-] it's a study of the pain of being single,- time and again one senses not only that Mildred is suffering but that nobody can see why she shouldn't suffer, like a Victorian cabhorse. " And again in a letter of 1971 he praised the book, - "what a marvellous set of characters it contains! My only criticism is that Mildred is a tiny bit too humble at times, but perhaps she's satirising herself. I never see any Rockys, but almost every young academic wife ('I'm a shit') has something of Helena."[13]

Adaptations

The novel was serialised as a radio play in the 1950s on the BBC Women's Hour.[14]

Excellent Women was serialised in 10 parts on BBC Radio 4's Books at Bedtime programme, read by Deborah Findlay [15]

Connections to other novels

Barbara Pym's characters often reappear or are referenced in later novels. In Jane and Prudence (1953), one of the characters mentions that "nice Miss Lathbury" has married an anthropologist (presumably Everard). In Less than Angels (1955), Everard reappears as a character, described as "having married a rather dull woman who was nevertheless a great help to him in his work; as a clergyman's daughter she naturally got on very well with the missionaries that they were meeting now that they were in Africa again." Later Pym writes "Everard's wife Mildred would do the typing". Bone appears finally in An Unsuitable Attachment in which he attends a dinner party while his wife, Mildred, is at home sick.[8]

This novel also introduces the anthropologist's assistant Esther Clovis, who will feature in the novels Less Than Angels and An Unsuitable Attachment, and whose funeral service will appear from different perspectives in both An Academic Question and A Few Green Leaves. The character of Archdeacon Hoccleve in Excellent Women had previously played a larger role in Pym's first novel, Some Tame Gazelle.

References

1. Alexander McCall Smith, The Guardian, 5 April 2008
2. "Excellent Women". Barbara Pym Society. Retrieved 18 August 2020.
3. Alexander McCall Smith (5 April 200). "Barbara Pym's Excellent Women: 'One of the 20th century's most amusing novels'". The Guardian. Retrieved 2 June 2019.
4. Cannon, Catriona, Whatever we hereafter write, 'tis thy Posterity', paper published in Green Leaves: The Journal of the Barbara Pym Society, Autumn 2015, p.5
5. Beverly Bell. "A Close Look at Chapter 1 of Excellent Women" (PDF). Retrieved 12 March 2020. Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
6. Triona Adams. "'But I have that within that passeth show': The Polite Sufferings of Spinster Life in the Narrative Voice of Excellent Women" (PDF). Retrieved 12 March 2020. Cite journal requires |journal= (help)
7. Deb Fisher (2015). "A Suitable Attachment: Partnerships in Excellent Women" (PDF). Barbara Pym Society. Retrieved 27 June 2020.
8. Victoria Patterson (July 16, 2015). "A Nice Hobby, Like Knitting: On Barbara Pym". LA Review of Books. Retrieved 27 June 2020.
9. Holt, Hazel (1990). A Lot to Ask: A Life of Barbara Pym. London: Macmillan. p. 160. ISBN 0525249370.
10. Holt 1990, p.194
11. Holt 1990, p.275
12. Holt 1990, p.154
13. Selected letters of Philip Larkin, Faber 1992, p.368, 442
14. Pym, Barbara (1984). A Very Private Eye: An Autobiography in Diaries and Letters (ed. Hazel Holt and Hilary Pym). New York: E.P. Dutton. p. 184. ISBN 0525242341.
15. A Few Green Leaves: The Journal of the Barbara Pym Society, Vol 8 No. 1, May 2002

External links