Yoruba Girl Dancing

Yoruba Girl Dancing is the debut novel of Nigerian author Simi Bedford, which "tackles the weighty and painful issue of the extent to which Africans, even those who are members of the privileged classes, can gain social acceptance in 'the West.'"[1] Yoruba Girl Dancing was first published in Great Britain in 1991 (by William Heinemann Ltd) and then in the United States in 1992 (by Viking Books). It is extracted in the 2019 anthology New Daughters of Africa.[2][3]

Story

The novel is about Remi Foster, an intelligent Yoruba girl who, at the age of six, journeys from her home and privileged life in Lagos, Nigeria, to receive an education in England. After years of living abroad, Remi begins to consider herself an Englishwoman rather than a Nigerian, despite facing considerable discrimination in English private schools. A bildungsroman (coming-of-age novel), the book focuses on issues of identity in the postcolonial period.[4][5] The Yoruba people are one of the largest ethnic groups in Nigeria, making up 21 per cent of that country's population.

Major characters

Remi Foster - A Nigerian girl sent at the age of six to attend a boarding school in England, Remi is the titular protagonist and narrator.[6] The novel follows her from childhood to adulthood, chronicling her education within several English private schools, her experiences staying with various English families, and her eventual return to Nigeria. Remi is smart, sharp and well educated, though somewhat naïve due to her age, particularly in the first half of the novel. During her stay in England, she grapples with cultural indoctrination and racial bigotry, as well as her peers’ views of stereotypes of black Africans.[6]

Miss Pickering / "Bigmama" – An Englishwoman who married into the Foster family, Miss Pickering — known to Remi as Bigmama — helps to prepare Remi for life in England.[1] Bigmama, who married a Nigerian man, has experienced at first hand the racial and cultural conflict present in post-colonial England. Knowing full well that a Nigerian child will face racial discrimination in London, Bigmama does her best to groom young Remi for English society. Though well-meaning, her efforts often come off as callous to the reader.

Miss Smith – A short, youthful English woman who "tutors" Remi on board the ship to Liverpool. Miss Smith berates Remi for wandering the ship unattended, dismisses the young girl's intelligence, and generally serves as a nuisance to Remi during the voyage.[1]

Mr Lowther – A boatswain on the cargo liner to Liverpool, Mr Lowther forms an unlikely friendship with the protagonist. He shows Remi around the ship and its crew quarters, remarking that only the two of them can "move freely" between the cargo liner's dual worlds.[1] Kind and considerate, Mr Lowther serves as a foil to the unsympathetic Miss Smith.

Remi's parents – Absent for most of the novel, Remi's parents first appear only to send Remi off to England for an education.[7] They meet with Remi once again, much later, this time bringing along Remi's younger sister, Aduke, and younger brother, Tunji. As head of an upper class Nigerian family, Remi's father's behaviour in public is a frequent source of shock for English strangers.

Families – During her stay in England, Remi houses with many different families, all of them acquaintances of the Foster family. In general, these families are a source of discontent for Remi, who feels out of place and unwanted in their homes, particularly later in the novel.

Aduke – Remi's younger sister, who serves as a foil to Remi in the final quarter of the novel. While Remi has decided, by this point in the narrative, that excessive flattery and charm is the best method by which to deal with new English families, Aduke refuses to assume such false identities. She views Remi's efforts to charm strangers and conform to English culture as not only vain but embarrassing.

Plot synopsis

The novel begins with Remi Foster, aged six, living with her grandparents and their foster children in Nigeria. When her parents return home from a wedding reception, they bring surprising news: she is being sent to live in an all-girls boarding-school in England.[1] "Bigmama", an Englishwoman who married into the Foster family, will bring Remi along on her return trip to Liverpool. Remi is shocked by the news; she knew "everyone went to England", but she never expected to leave at such a young age.

Although overcome with excitement at the prospect of attending an English school, she is understandably disheartened by some of the measures Bigmama takes to ensure that her transition into English society goes as smoothly as possible. Bigmama insists that Remi's hair be cut short, as she believes English hairdressers won't know how to style it properly. She also purchases an oversized raincoat and matching hat for Remi to wear, both of which are large enough to conceal her skin colour from prying eyes. Remi, at her young age, does not fully understand the reasoning behind the outfit, nor its implications.

Remi and Bigmama set sail for England on a cargo liner. On the first morning, Remi leaves her cabin and explores the ship, clad in nothing but her nightgown. She is discovered by Miss Smith, who drags her back to Bigmama, offering to tutor Remi during the voyage. Remi feigns illness to escape Miss Smith, sneaks out of her cabin, and stumbles into the crew quarters, where she meets Mr Lowther. She spends most of the remaining voyage with Lowther, learning about the ship and listening to the crew's stories.

Upon arriving in England, Remi meets Aunty Madge, Bigmama's sister, and Uncle Reg. Remi learns that she will be staying with Aunty Betty and Uncle Theo, though the two are reluctant to house her. Shortly afterwards, Remi moves into the boarding school. Though initially shunned because of her skin colour, which one girl claims will "rub off" on anyone who brushes against her, Remi manages to gain the trust of her schoolmates, by fabricating exotic, stereotypical tales of Africa, and pretending that her father is a chieftain.[8]

Years pass, and Remi transfers from school to school. She is now more English than Nigerian, and her home in Lagos seems a distant memory. She has become wiser, jaded, somewhat cynical. She is, by all accounts, an Englishwoman, yet her skin colour makes her an outsider. During the novel Remi never returns to Nigeria, where she would no longer be a strange outsider to be shunned, but an intriguing and cultured individual among her peers.

Themes

Race

Race is an important theme in Yoruba Girl Dancing as it is perhaps the largest obstacle facing the main character. During Remi's time in Lagos, race is less evident as an issue, since almost everyone she has contact with is black; however, there are a few key moments during which the reader begins to understand the role of race in Nigeria. Remi and her family are distinguished as unique and wealthy because they live in an area where mostly wealthy expatriates and white people reside. Furthermore, the fact that the inclusion of a white woman from England in their family is such an affront to Remi's conservative grandmother shows that the stigma of race goes both ways, not just of white people towards black people.

However, this is turned on its head once Remi arrives in England. Before going to boarding-school she spends time in London with her white step-grandmother, Bigmama, and some of her relatives. Remi takes a liking to these people and asks to see them during her school breaks but it is made clear that her white “Aunt” is uncomfortable with this because of what others will think of a white woman serving as the guardian for a black girl. Remi faces more of such prejudice once she arrives at school. The white women running the school have little sympathy for the six-year-old and the harshness of the transition she is facing as a young Nigerian girl coming to a posh boarding-school where she is not only the single African but the only black girl. Furthermore, the school uniform is referred to as being "nigger" brown, and the girls she must share living quarters with are under the assumption that her blackness is contagious.[9]

By the end of the novel Remi comes to the satisfying conclusion that, despite all the strife she has faced in Britain, she is in fact British.[7] She is able to overcome her internal issues regarding race and firmly declare herself within one of the two realms that she has always straddled.

The total effect of the many moments in the novel concerning race is to inform the reader of exactly how severe the stigma of blackness in 1950s London was, one that no amount of money or education would allow a black person to completely escape.

Socio-economic class

When the reader is introduced to Remi, she is living with her very wealthy grandparents in Lagos, Nigeria.[1] They have an enormous colonial style home with multiple floors and many servants, who live in separate quarters on the grounds.[8] Wealth isolates Remi from those around her. Her maids, close to her in age but so different in their means and class, are the nearest things she has to friends, yet there is always a level of disconnect among them, made even more evident when Remi takes a trip to the marketplace with one of the servants who works in her grandparents' home. Remi is dressed in English-style clothing and is taunted by some girls for it. Also, the scale, lavishness, and attention that the wedding of one of her family members receives indicates just how wealthy her family is and the high-profile this wealth affords them.

When six-year-old Remi makes the trip from Nigeria to England she stays with some relatives of her step-grandmother, Bigmama. Remi immediately notices that they do not have servants and the woman of the house does the housework herself. Remi assumes that they are poor. Following her stay in London with these distant relatives, she goes to boarding-school with other affluent girls. However, because of her race, these girls do not believe she could possibly have lived a lavish lifestyle in Nigeria and she is isolated from her classmates.

The divide that socio-economic status causes in Remi's life underscores her constant feeling of isolation. She is never among those who are like her, and in order to adapt to the rifts caused by her race and socio-economic class, she must develop into a strong and somewhat cynical young woman.

Colonialism

Colonialism and post-colonialism are major themes of the novel.[10] Coming from a wealthy family in colonial Lagos, Remi basically lives in a European African culture – she lives in Africa yet everything around her has European influence. She lives in a big house with servants and is part of the Nigerian upper class for whom British culture is a dominant influence.

Colonization by the British has a huge impact on Remi and her family in almost everything, including a European style of beauty. Remi compares herself to European actresses and wishes she looked like them. She wears English clothes. Early on in the novel, she makes the mistake of wearing her English clothes to the market, where she runs into girls who are not of the same class as she is and are wearing traditional African clothes. They corner her and tease and harass her for following what the Europeans do and letting them colonize her even more. It is almost disrespectful to them that she is wearing English attire – clothes from a country that colonized theirs.

Remi going to boarding-school in England is another representation of colonialism and the British influence over Africa. Her wealthy family believe that being educated in Europe is a way for Remi to better herself.

Cultural references

The story in Yoruba Girl Dancing of Remi Foster's eventful journey to London from Nigeria closely relates to the life of author Simi Bedford, who experienced a similar childhood.[7] In addition to being partially autobiographical, the novel also alludes to other books, singers, and aspects of culture that proved to have an influence on the writing of Yoruba Girl Dancing.

When Remi auditions for her school choir, she turns out to be an awful singer, and after the audition the teacher perplexed says: "I assumed you would have a beautiful voice like Paul Robeson, like all your people" (125). Such gross generalizations recur elsewhere in the book, as Remi struggles to achieve equality with her classmates.. One classmate, Anita, convinces the other girls that Remi's skin colour rubs off (86). Such incidents plague Remi's early life in the foreign country.

Towards the end of the novel, Remi compares her life to that of Shakespeare's Othello. In the Tragedy of Othello, Desdemona’s father could not fathom why she would love a black man. When talking to her friend Phoebe, Remi notes of her teacher: "I’m sure he thinks I’m using some kind of voodoo to woo the language to me in the same way Brabantio accused Othello of using spells on Desdemona" (172). Remi realizes that she has spent her whole life trying to become an Englishwoman, just as Othello attempted to become a Venetian, before ultimately committing suicide. She concludes that she has lost sight of who she once was. At this moment, she is aware that she will never be fully accepted in English society. Despite the friendships made while studying abroad, there will always be people who stare at her and question her upbringing and race.

In the book's last pages, as Remi is dancing with her friends and family, her life comes full circle. She is once again with her native culture, after experiencing the difficulties of living in a foreign country, and is completely content. The final line of the novel states: "Is there a sight more beautiful, the older women said, than a Yoruba girl dancing?" Remi's genuine happiness to be reunited with her mother, brothers, sisters, and friends shows through her exotic, cultural dancing.

Historical background

The story is set in 1950s' Nigeria and England. Nigeria gained its independence from Britain in early 1960. After the many years of colonization and invasion by the European nation, the country was later freed from foreign control. Although Independence marked a monumental achievement for the country, Nigeria still had prolonged foreign influence or rule. The author of the novel relates the issues of colonialism, class, and race to the main character's life and as well as their key role in Nigerian society. All these themes relate to one another and exemplify the nation's attitude in the 1950s. For example, Remi is sent to England by her parents to further her education in the belief that the opportunity to study abroad is a way to better oneself. Throughout the novel, issues such as class and race also appear, showing the struggles faced both by Remi and the Nigerian people.

The atmosphere surrounding Remi parallels the nation's struggle with colonization, race, and the class system. For instance, her battle with her identity specifically highlights racial issues. As the students in her classroom mock her for her very different appearance, Remi tries to look more like everybody else. At one point, the pressures of society make her hate her African features and favour the popular European look.

The novel's intriguing title, Yoruba Girl Dancing, directly signals to readers who Remi is, where she is from, and her cultural background: she is a Yoruba girl dancing in the midst of confusion as to where to belong, struggling with her identity, whether she is British or African. Represented in this novel is the rich and complex history of Nigeria interacting with foreign influences, and the many underlying issues this brings about.

Reception and reviews

Publishers Weekly emphasises the racial issues that Yoruba Girl Dancing addresses: "...she is deposited at the upper-crust Chilcott Manor School (where the uniform tunic is 'nigger brown')... [the] family must endure the scrutiny and derision of her classmate, one of whom spreads the word that 'the black rubs off'..." The review concludes: "Bedford, a native of Nigeria who moved to Britain as a child and now lives in London, has written a wise and provocative book that might even prompt some soul-searching in the social circles she has skewered."[9]
Kirkus Reviews′ description said: "Funny, touching debut .... Evocative story of coming-of-age, cultural transformations, and continuities."[11]
An Amazon Customer Review by Alicia Giutna is quite critical of the book and Bedford's writing. Although, Giutna states that the book is an easy read, she posts that Yoruba Girl Dancing would not appeal to adults because of the immaturity within the characters and their relationships with one another in the story.[12]
GoodReads: Barbara loved the book and compares it to the story Revolutionary Road. She seems concerned primarily with the distance and disconnect of emotions in all of the characters in the book, and in all of the relationships that the characters share with one another.[13]
Barnes & Noble: Editorial Reviews – "From the Critics": Janet Ingraham enjoyed the book, however, felt that it was hurried and "faltered" towards the end. Ingraham seemed to love Remi, but not Bedford, "the sympathetic, witty narrator and the issues her story raises recommend this flawed but pleasing, exuberant novel."[14]
The Washington Post review by Francine Prose, in September 1992, said:
"...given the increasing frequency with which political boundaries are being redrawn and the resultant mushrooming of refugee populations, the novel of the future may well be the novel of immigration: fictions in which characters are relocated to alien lands and forced to contend with a dizzying array of new obstacles and perils, from innocent crosscultural misunderstanding to flat-out jingoist hysteria.

If the coming decades do in fact bring a wave of such novels, Simi Bedford's appealing, witty and intelligent Yoruba Girl Dancing is very much in advance of the landing. ... Beautifully written, Yoruba Girl Dancing is at once acerbic and moving, painfully honest about the cost of emigration and adjustment."[15]

Radio abridgement

In October 1991, a five-part abridgement of Yoruba Girl Dancing (by Margaret Busby, read by Adjoa Andoh and produced by David Hunter) was broadcast on BBC Radio 4's Book at Bedtime.[16]

References

Gagiano, Annie (16 December 2014). "African Library: Yoruba Girl Dancing by Simi Bedford". LitNet. Retrieved 3 February 2016.
Busby, Margaret (9 March 2019), "From Ayòbámi Adébáyò to Zadie Smith: meet the New Daughters of Africa", The Guardian.
New Daughters of Africa contributors, Myriad Editions.
Donelley, Gabrielle (1 December 1992). "A fleet first novel that's worth slowing down for". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved 7 December 2011.
Ogundipe-Leslie, Molara (9 November 1991). "The high cost of a British education". Toronto Star. Retrieved 7 December 2011.
Ingraham, Janet (1992). "Book Reviews: Fiction". Library Journal. 117 (14): 210. Retrieved 3 February 2016 – via EBSCO.
McGill, Nancy (15 February 1993). "Word of Mouth". Library Journal. 118 (3): 224. Retrieved 3 February 2016 – via EBSCO.
Japtok, Martin (2001). "Two Postcolonial Childhoods: Merle Hodge's Crick Crack, Monkey and Simi Bedford's Yoruba Girl Dancing". West Virginia State College. Retrieved 3 February 2016.
"Yoruba Girl Dancing" (review), Publishers Weekly, 28 September 1992.
Hodapp, James, "The Proto-Afropolitan Bildungsroman: Yoruba Women, Resistance, and the Nation in Simi Bedford's Yoruba Girl Dancing", The Global South, Volume 10, Number 1, Spring 2016, pp. 130–149.
"Yoruba Girl Dancing", Kirkus Reviews, 15 July 1992.
"Amazon Customer Reviews: Alicia Giutna, 19 May 2002.
Barbara, GoodReads, 17 January 2009.
Janet Ingraham, "From the Critics", Barnes & Noble.
Prose, Francine (27 September 1992), "England through young African eyes", Washington Post.
"Listings", Radio Times, Issue 3539, 23 October 1991, p. 93.