We Come in Peace
We Come in Peace was a commissioned art installation created by Huma Bhabha, a New York–based Pakistani-American sculptor, for the Iris and B. Gerald Cantor Roof Garden of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. The installation was planned to be on display from April 17, 2018, to October 28, 2018.[1] The installation consisted of two sculptures, named We Come in Peace and Benaam, which means "nameless" in Urdu.[2] We Come in Peace was a 12 ft (3.7 m) tall standing figure, while Benaam was a 18 ft (5.5 m) long figure lying prostrate.[2][3] According to AM New York, the We Come in Peace sculpture was gender fluid.[3]
| We Come in Peace | |
|---|---|
| Artist | Huma Bhabha |
| Medium | Sculpture |
| Dimensions | (12 feet (We Come in Peace) 18 feet (Benaam) ) |
| Location | Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, New York |
Description
The sculptures were made of clay, styrofoam, and cork, then cast in bronze to allow them to withstand the elements.[4][5] The title of the installation makes reference to a 1951 film, The Day the Earth Stood Still.[6] According to AM New York, Bhabha viewed the characters as cooperative, with We Come in Peace coming to aid Benaam, but arriving too late because Benaam has already died – though to her mind the latter might still "rise up ... [t]hings that you would not imagine might happen. That's the hope."[3]
While Bhabha considers the work to be "very much an anti-war statement", she also wanted it to be multi-layered and open to a wide variety of interpretations.[3]
Critical reception
Scott Lynch of Gothamist, remarking on the pieces' diversity of inspiration, observed, "Both pieces allude to a wide swath of art history, from ancient African and Indian sculpture to contemporary works by the likes of Basquiat and David Hammons".[6] He said that the sculptures created an "ominous but open-ended narrative, inviting visitors to explore their own thematic interpretations: subjugation and supplication, respect, fear, and/or adoration; social upheaval and displacement; gender, power, and 'memories of place.'"[6]
Martha Schwendener of The New York Times described the installation as "a spare and unsettling sculptural installation", that "ripples" with associations of "colonization, invasion, imperialism".[5] She suggests that the work invites the observer to consider the sheer strangeness of extraterrestrial or "post-humanity" lifeforms as they would likely be experienced by humankind, but that such encounters may ultimately offer the possibility of a "melding of cultures and aesthetics that might be harmonious rather than imperialist."[5]
Describing the work as "eerie, other, unnerving, ambiguous, even alarming",[7] Jerry Saltz for Vulture saw the work as a critique of the West: its "vivisected, gouged idol covered in blotchy graffiti could be from any photograph seen daily of the mayhem in the Middle East, just part of the carnage, interventions, and wars [Bhabha] has called a 'systematic demonization and humiliation of the people and their ancient and present Islamic cultures' ... [h]er Met installation is a vivid rebuke of what the West says to all the cultures it invades: We come in peace."[7] He assessed the work as "among the best Met roof sculpture installations since the program began in 1987."[7]
References
- "Otherworldly Figures Have Landed on The Met's Rooftop Garden". Untapped Cities. 2018-04-18. Retrieved 2019-06-20.
- "The Roof Garden Commission: Huma Bhabha, We Come in Peace". www.metmuseum.org. Retrieved 2019-06-20.
- Ordweiler, Cory. "The Met's rooftop sci-fi-themed exhibit is now open". am New York. Retrieved 2019-06-20.
- "They 'Come in Peace' But They've Been Through Hell: Huma Bhabha Brings Her Battle-Scarred Figures to the Met Rooftop". artnet News. 2018-04-17. Retrieved 2019-06-20.
- Schwendener, Martha (2018-04-12). "A Sci-Fi Showdown at the Met Museum's Rooftop Garden". The New York Times. ISSN 0362-4331. Retrieved 2019-06-20.
- Lynch, Scott (2018-04-17). "The Met Rooftop's Installation, "We Come In Peace," Has Landed". Gothamist. Retrieved 2019-06-20.
- Saltz, Jerry (2018-05-18). "Huma Bhabha's New Installation at the Met Brings You Into the Realm of Gods". www.vulture.com. Retrieved 2019-06-20.
Further reading
- Jhaveri, Shanay; Halter, Ed; Wagstaff, Sheena (2018). The Roof Garden Commission: Huma Bhabha, We Come in Peace. Metropolitan Museum of Art. ISBN 978-1-58839-646-4. Retrieved July 27, 2019. (Exhibition catalogue)