Thin-film interference

Thin-film interference is a natural phenomenon in which light waves reflected by the upper and lower boundaries of a thin film interfere with one another, either enhancing or reducing the reflected light. When the thickness of the film is an odd multiple of one quarter-wavelength of the light on it, the reflected waves from both surfaces interfere to cancel each other. Since the wave cannot be reflected, it is completely transmitted instead. When the thickness is a multiple of a half-wavelength of the light, the two reflected waves reinforce each other, increasing the reflection and reducing the transmission. Thus when white light, which consists of a range of wavelengths, is incident on the film, certain wavelengths (colors) are intensified while others are attenuated. Thin-film interference explains the multiple colors seen in light reflected from soap bubbles and oil films on water. It is also the mechanism behind the action of antireflection coatings used on glasses and camera lenses.

A colorful interference pattern is observed when light is reflected from the top and bottom boundaries of a thin oil film. The different bands form as the film's thickness diminishes from a central runoff-point.

Colors in light reflected from a soap bubble

A laser output coupler is coated with a multitude of films stacked atop each other, to achieve a reflectivity of 80% at 550nm. Left: The mirror is highly reflective to yellow and green but highly transmissive to red and blue. Right: The mirror transmists 25% of the 589nm laser light.

The true thickness of the film depends on both its refractive index and on the angle of incidence of the light. The speed of light is slower in a higher-index medium; thus a film is manufactured in proportion to the wavelength as it passes through the film. At a normal angle of incidence, the thickness will typically be a quarter or half multiple of the center wavelength, but at an oblique angle of incidence, the thickness will be equal to the cosine of the angle at the quarter or half-wavelength positions, which accounts for the changing colors as the viewing angle changes. (For any certain thickness, the color will shift from a shorter to a longer wavelength as the angle changes from normal to oblique.) This constructive/destructive interference produces narrow reflection/transmission bandwidths, so the observed colors are rarely separate wavelengths, such as produced by a diffraction grating or prism, but a mixture of various wavelengths absent of others in the spectrum. Therefore, the colors observed are rarely those of the rainbow, but browns, golds, turquoises, teals, bright blues, purples, and magentas. Studying the light reflected or transmitted by a thin film can reveal information about the thickness of the film or the effective refractive index of the film medium. Thin films have many commercial applications including anti-reflection coatings, mirrors, and optical filters.

Theory

Demonstration of the optical path length difference for light reflected from the upper and lower boundaries of a thin film.

Thin-film interference caused by ITO defrosting coating on an Airbus cockpit window.

In optics, a thin film is a layer of material with thickness in the sub-nanometer to micron range. As light strikes the surface of a film it is either transmitted or reflected at the upper surface. Light that is transmitted reaches the bottom surface and may once again be transmitted or reflected. The Fresnel equations provide a quantitative description of how much of the light will be transmitted or reflected at an interface. The light reflected from the upper and lower surfaces will interfere. The degree of constructive or destructive interference between the two light waves depends on the difference in their phase. This difference in turn depends on the thickness of the film layer, the refractive index of the film, and the angle of incidence of the original wave on the film. Additionally, a phase shift of 180° or ${\displaystyle \pi }$ radians may be introduced upon reflection at a boundary depending on the refractive indices of the materials on either side of the boundary. This phase shift occurs if the refractive index of the medium the light is travelling through is less than the refractive index of the material it is striking. In other words, if ${\displaystyle n_{1}<n_{2}}$ and the light is travelling from material 1 to material 2, then a phase shift occurs upon reflection. The pattern of light that results from this interference can appear either as light and dark bands or as colorful bands depending upon the source of the incident light.

Consider light incident on a thin film and reflected by both the upper and lower boundaries. The optical path difference (OPD) of the reflected light must be calculated in order to determine the condition for interference. Referring to the ray diagram above, the OPD between the two waves is the following:

${\displaystyle OPD=n_{2}({\overline {AB}}+{\overline {BC}})-n_{1}({\overline {AD}})}$

Where,

${\displaystyle {\overline {AB}}={\overline {BC}}={\frac {d}{\cos(\theta _{2})}}}$

${\displaystyle {\overline {AD}}=2d\tan(\theta _{2})\sin(\theta _{1})}$

Using Snell's law, ${\displaystyle n_{1}\sin(\theta _{1})=n_{2}\sin(\theta _{2})}$

${\displaystyle {\begin{aligned}OPD&=n_{2}\left({\frac {2d}{\cos(\theta _{2})}}\right)-2d\tan(\theta _{2})n_{2}\sin(\theta _{2})\\&=2n_{2}d\left({\frac {1-\sin ^{2}(\theta _{2})}{\cos(\theta _{2})}}\right)\\&=2n_{2}d\cos {\big (}\theta _{2})\\\end{aligned}}}$

Interference will be constructive if the optical path difference is equal to an integer multiple of the wavelength of light, ${\displaystyle \lambda }$.

${\displaystyle 2n_{2}d\cos {\big (}\theta _{2})=m\lambda }$

This condition may change after considering possible phase shifts that occur upon reflection.

Monochromatic source

Gasoline on water shows a pattern of bright and dark fringes when illuminated with 589nm laser light.

Where incident light is monochromatic in nature, interference patterns appear as light and dark bands. Light bands correspond to regions at which constructive interference is occurring between the reflected waves and dark bands correspond to destructive interference regions. As the thickness of the film varies from one location to another, the interference may change from constructive to destructive. A good example of this phenomenon, termed "Newton's rings," demonstrates the interference pattern that results when light is reflected from a spherical surface adjacent to a flat surface. Concentric rings are observed when the surface is illuminated with monochromatic light. This phenomenon is used with optical flats to measure the shape and flatness of surfaces.

Broadband source

If the incident light is broadband, or white, such as light from the sun, interference patterns appear as colorful bands. Different wavelengths of light create constructive interference for different film thicknesses. Different regions of the film appear in different colors depending on the local film thickness.

Phase interaction

Constructive phase interaction

Destructive phase interaction

The figures show two incident light beams (A and B). Each beam produces a reflected beam (dashed). The reflections of interest are beam A’s reflection off of the lower surface and beam B’s reflection off of the upper surface. These reflected beams combine to produce a resultant beam (C). If the reflected beams are in phase (as in the first figure) the resultant beam is relatively strong. If, on the other hand, the reflected beams have opposite phase, the resulting beam is attenuated (as in the second figure).

The phase relationship of the two reflected beams depends on the relationship between the wavelength of beam A in the film, and the film's thickness. If the total distance beam A travels in the film is an integer multiple of the wavelength of the beam in the film, then the two reflected beams are in phase and constructively interfere (as depicted in the first figure). If the distance traveled by beam A is an odd integer multiple of the half wavelength of light in the film, the beams destructively interfere (as in the second figure). Thus, the film shown in these figures reflects more strongly at the wavelength of the light beam in the first figure, and less strongly at that of the beam in the second figure.

Examples

The type of interference that occurs when light is reflected from a thin film is dependent upon the wavelength and angle of the incident light, the thickness of the film, the refractive indices of the material on either side of the film, and the index of the film medium. Various possible film configurations and the related equations are explained in more detail in the examples below.

Soap bubble

Thin film interference in a soap bubble. Color varies with film thickness.

Light incident on a soap film in air

In the case of a soap bubble, light travels through air and strikes a soap film. The air has a refractive index of 1 (${\displaystyle n_{\rm {air}}=1}$) and the film has an index that is larger than 1 (${\displaystyle n_{\rm {film}}>1}$). The reflection that occurs at the upper boundary of the film (the air-film boundary) will introduce a 180° phase shift in the reflected wave because the refractive index of the air is less than the index of the film (${\displaystyle n_{\rm {air}}<n_{\rm {film}}}$). Light that is transmitted at the upper air-film interface will continue to the lower film-air interface where it can be reflected or transmitted. The reflection that occurs at this boundary will not change the phase of the reflected wave because ${\displaystyle n_{\rm {film}}>n_{\rm {air}}}$. The condition for interference for a soap bubble is the following:

${\displaystyle 2n_{\rm {film}}d\cos(\theta _{2})=\left(m-{\frac {1}{2}}\right)\lambda }$  for constructive interference of reflected light

${\displaystyle 2n_{\rm {film}}d\cos {\big (}\theta _{2})=m\lambda }$  for destructive interference of reflected light

Where ${\displaystyle d}$ is the film thickness, ${\displaystyle n_{\rm {film}}}$ is the refractive index of the film, ${\displaystyle \theta _{2}}$ is the angle of incidence of the wave on the lower boundary, ${\displaystyle m}$ is an integer, and ${\displaystyle \lambda }$ is the wavelength of light.

Oil film

Light incident on an oil film on water

In the case of a thin oil film, a layer of oil sits on top of a layer of water. The oil may have an index of refraction near 1.5 and the water has an index of 1.33. As in the case of the soap bubble, the materials on either side of the oil film (air and water) both have refractive indices that are less than the index of the film. ${\displaystyle n_{\rm {air}}<n_{\rm {water}}<n_{\rm {oil}}}$. There will be a phase shift upon reflection from the upper boundary because ${\displaystyle n_{\rm {air}}<n_{\rm {oil}}}$ but no shift upon reflection from the lower boundary because ${\displaystyle n_{\rm {oil}}>n_{\rm {water}}}$. The equations for interference will be the same.

${\displaystyle 2n_{\rm {oil}}d\cos(\theta _{2})=\left(m-{\frac {1}{2}}\right)\lambda }$  for constructive interference of reflected light

${\displaystyle 2n_{\rm {oil}}d\cos {\big (}\theta _{2})=m\lambda }$  for destructive interference of reflected light

Anti-reflection coatings

Light incident on an anti-reflection coating on glass

An anti-reflection coating eliminates reflected light and maximizes transmitted light in an optical system. A film is designed such that reflected light produces destructive interference and transmitted light produces constructive interference for a given wavelength of light. In the simplest implementation of such a coating, the film is created so that its optical thickness ${\displaystyle dn_{\rm {coating}}}$ is a quarter-wavelength of the incident light and its refractive index is greater than the index of air and less than the index of glass.

${\displaystyle n_{\rm {air}}<n_{\rm {coating}}<n_{\rm {glass}}}$

${\displaystyle d=\lambda /(4n_{\rm {coating}})}$

A 180° phase shift will be induced upon reflection at both the top and bottom interfaces of the film because ${\displaystyle n_{\rm {air}}<n_{\rm {coating}}}$ and ${\displaystyle n_{\rm {coating}}<n_{\rm {glass}}}$. The equations for interference of the reflected light are:

${\displaystyle 2n_{\rm {coating}}d\cos {\big (}\theta _{2})=m\lambda }$  for constructive interference

${\displaystyle 2n_{\rm {coating}}d\cos(\theta _{2})=\left(m-{\frac {1}{2}}\right)\lambda }$  for destructive interference

If the optical thickness ${\displaystyle dn_{\rm {coating}}}$ is equal to a quarter-wavelength of the incident light and if the light strikes the film at normal incidence ${\displaystyle (\theta _{2}=0)}$, the reflected waves will be completely out of phase and will destructively interfere. Further reduction in reflection is possible by adding more layers, each designed to match a specific wavelength of light.

Interference of transmitted light is completely constructive for these films.

In nature

Structural coloration due to thin-film layers is common in the natural world. The wings of many insects act as thin films because of their minimal thickness. This is clearly visible in the wings of many flies and wasps. In butterflies, the thin-film optics are visible when the wing itself is not covered by pigmented wing scales, which is the case in the blue wing spots of the Aglais io butterfly.[1] The glossy appearance of buttercup flowers is also due to a thin film[2][3] as well as the shiny breast feathers of the bird of paradise.[4]

• 
  The blue wing patches of the Aglais io butterfly are due to thin-film interference.[1]
• 
  The gloss of buttercup flowers is due to thin-film interference.[2]

Applications

An antireflection-coated optical window. At a 45° angle the coating is slightly thicker to the incident light, causing the center wavelength to shift toward the red and reflections appear at the violet end of the spectrum. At 0°, for which this coating was designed, almost no reflection is observed.

Thin films are used commercially in anti-reflection coatings, mirrors, and optical filters. They can be engineered to control the amount of light reflected or transmitted at a surface for a given wavelength. A Fabry–Pérot etalon takes advantage of thin film interference to selectively choose which wavelengths of light are allowed to transmit through the device. These films are created through deposition processes in which material is added to a substrate in a controlled manner. Methods include chemical vapor deposition and various physical vapor deposition techniques.

Thin films are also found in nature. Many animals have a layer of tissue behind the retina, the Tapetum lucidum, that aids in light collecting. The effects of thin-film interference can also be seen in oil slicks and soap bubbles. The reflectance spectrum of a thin-film features distinct oscillations and the extrema of the spectrum can be used to calculate the thickness of the thin-film.[1]

Ellipsometry is a technique that is often used to measure properties of thin films. In a typical ellipsometry experiment polarized light is reflected off a film surface and is measured by a detector. The complex reflectance ratio, ${\displaystyle \rho }$, of the system is measured. A model analysis in then conducted in which this information is used to determine film layer thicknesses and refractive indices.

Dual polarisation interferometry is an emerging technique for measuring refractive index and thickness of molecular scale thin films and how these change when stimulated.

History

Tempering colors are produced when steel is heated and a thin film of iron oxide forms on the surface. The color indicates the temperature the steel reached, which made this one of the earliest practical uses of thin-film interference.

Iridescent interference colors in an oil film

Iridescence caused by thin-film interference is a commonly observed phenomenon in nature, being found in a variety of plants and animals. One of the first known studies of this phenomenon was conducted by Robert Hooke in 1665. In Micrographia, Hooke postulated that the iridescence in peacock feathers was caused by thin, alternating layers of plate and air. In 1704, Isaac Newton stated in his book, Opticks, that the iridescence in a peacock feather was due to the fact that the transparent layers in the feather were so thin.[5] In 1801, Thomas Young provided the first explanation of constructive and destructive interference. Young's contribution went largely unnoticed until the work of Augustin Fresnel, who helped to establish the wave theory of light in 1816.[6] However, very little explanation could be made of the iridescence until the 1870s, when James Maxwell and Heinrich Hertz helped to explain the electromagnetic nature of light.[5] After the invention of the Fabry–Perot interferometer, in 1899, the mechanisms of thin-film interference could be demonstrated on a larger scale.[6]

In much of the early work, scientists tried to explain iridescence, in animals like peacocks and scarab beetles, as some form of surface color, such as a dye or pigment that might alter the light when reflected from different angles. In 1919, Lord Rayleigh proposed that the bright, changing colors were not caused by dyes or pigments, but by microscopic structures, which he termed "structural colors."[5] In 1923, C. W. Mason noted that the barbules in the peacock feather were made from very thin layers. Some of these layers were colored while others were transparent. He noticed that pressing the barbule would shift the color toward the blue, while swelling it with a chemical would shift it toward the red. He also found that bleaching the pigments from the feathers did not remove the iridescence. This helped to dispel the surface color theory and reinforce the structural color theory.[7]

In 1925, Ernest Merritt, in his paper A Spectrophotometric Study of Certain Cases of Structural Color, first described the process of thin-film interference as an explanation for the iridescence. The first examination of iridescent feathers by an electron microscope occurred in 1939, revealing complex thin-film structures, while an examination of the morpho butterfly, in 1942, revealed an extremely tiny array of thin-film structures on the nanometer scale.[5]

The first production of thin-film coatings occurred quite by accident. In 1817, Joseph Fraunhofer discovered that, by tarnishing glass with nitric acid, he could reduce the reflections on the surface. In 1819, after watching a layer of alcohol evaporate from a sheet of glass, Fraunhofer noted that colors appeared just before the liquid evaporated completely, deducing that any thin film of transparent material will produce colors.[6]

Little advancement was made in thin-film coating technology until 1936, when John Strong began evaporating fluorite in order to make anti-reflection coatings on glass. During the 1930s, improvements in vacuum pumps made vacuum deposition methods, like sputtering, possible. In 1939, Walter H. Geffcken created the first interference filters using dielectric coatings.[6]

See also

• Reflectometric interference spectroscopy
• Thin-film optics
• Transfer-matrix method (optics)

References

1. Stavenga, D. G. (2014). "Thin Film and Multilayer Optics Cause Structural Colors of Many Insects and Birds". Materials Today: Proceedings. 1: 109–121. doi:10.1016/j.matpr.2014.09.007.
2. Van Der Kooi, C. J.; Elzenga, J.T.M.; Dijksterhuis, J.; Stavenga, D.G. (2017). "Functional optics of glossy buttercup flowers". Journal of the Royal Society Interface. 14 (127): 20160933. doi:10.1098/rsif.2016.0933. PMC 5332578. PMID 28228540.
3. Van Der Kooi, C. J.; Wilts, B. D.; Leertouwer, H. L.; Staal, M.; Elzenga, J. T. M.; Stavenga, D. G. (2014). "Iridescent flowers? Contribution of surface structures to optical signaling" (PDF). New Phytologist. 203 (2): 667–73. doi:10.1111/nph.12808. PMID 24713039.
4. Stavenga, D. G.; Leertouwer, H. L.; Marshall, N. J.; Osorio, D. (2010). "Dramatic colour changes in a bird of paradise caused by uniquely structured breast feather barbules". Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 278 (1715): 2098–104. doi:10.1098/rspb.2010.2293. PMC 3107630. PMID 21159676.
5. Structural colors in the realm of nature By Shūichi Kinoshita – World Scientific Publishing 2008 pages 3–6
6. Thin-film optical filters By Hugh Angus Macleod – Institute of Physics Publishing 2001 Pages 1–4
7. Structural colors in the realm of nature By Shūichi Kinoshita - World Scientific Publishing 2008 Page 165-167

Further reading

• Fowles, Grant R. (1989), "Multiple-Beam Interference", Introduction to Modern Optics, Dover
• Greivenkamp, John (1995), "Interference", Handbook of Optics, McGraw–Hill
• Hecht, Eugene (2002), "Interference", Optics, Addison Wesley
• Knittl, Zdeněk (1976), Optics of Thin Films; An Optical Multilayer Theory, Wiley, Bibcode:1976otf..book.....K
• D.G. Stavenga, Thin film and multilayer optics cause structural colors of many insects and birds Materials today: Proceedings, 1S, 109 – 121 (2014).