Kerry Lyn Dalton
Kerry Lyn Dalton (born January 24, 1959) was convicted of first-degree murder in May 1995 and was sentenced to death by lethal injection the same year. Since her sentencing, she has been incarcerated at the Central California Women's Facility in Chowchilla, California,[2] awaiting her execution and appealing her death sentence. On May 16, 2019, the Supreme Court of California published their opinion on Ms Dalton's automatic appeal. The Justices found the charge of lying-in-wait and the charge of conspiracy were invalid; therefore they recommended that her sentence should be 25 years to life. The California Supreme Court did not invalidate the third death-qualified charge against Ms. Dalton; therefore she continues to be condemned. Although the Supreme Court issues opinions and can order a case to be re-tried, they do not enforce their opinions.[3][4]
Kerry Lyn Dalton | |
|---|---|
| Born | January 24, 1959[1] |
| Criminal status | Incarcerated at the Central California Women's Facility |
| Conviction(s) | Torture, Murder (23 May 1995) |
| Criminal penalty | Death Penalty |
Events of June 26, 1988
Dalton, accused of torturing and murdering Irene ("Melanie") Louise May on June 26, 1988 at a mobile home park in Live Oak Springs, California, was arrested on May 14, 1992.[5] She and three others, Mark Lee Tompkins, Sheryl Ann Baker, and another man known only by the name "George", were alleged to have used various weapons to commit a torture-murder: a cast-iron frying pan, a knife, and a syringe filled with battery acid.
The night of the alleged murder, when a Sheriff was called to the same mobile home residence on a burglary call, he reported no evidence of a burglary or any criminal activity other than that the resident, Ms. JoAnn Fedor, was high on methamphetamine. He searched inside and outside the residence and noted in his report the resident was a "5150", police code for mentally incapable to comprehend reality. No weapons nor any blood evidence was recovered; there was no physical evidence of any kind for the jury to consider. (trial transcripts: p. 2738–70, CR NO. 135002).[6]
Trial
On February 14, 1995, on the 6th day of Dalton's trial, the presiding judge, Thomas J. Whelan, made this statement: "I think the record is clear that no body has ever been found in this case. The record is equally clear that there is circumstantial evidence that there was a homicide. There's also conflicting circumstantial evidence that it may not be a homicide; in fact, she may still be alive ..." Whelan went on to say, "My reason for making these statements is to establish for the record that in my mind corpus is a legitimate issue in this case. It's not a ruse that - there is a legitimate issue before the jury as to whether or not there's - a corpus of a homicide has been established". (trial transcripts: p. 3507, CR NO. 135002).[6]
In response to a question from the prosecutor and an objection from the defense, the judge said, "Ladies and gentlemen, in the last question Mr. Dusek asked, he mentioned that the - Melanie May - in this case, is deceased. That's a fact for you to decide. It's inappropriate for him to put that in the question...whether or not Miss May is in fact deceased or not, because that's something for you to decide". (trial transcripts: p. 4661, CR NO. 135002)
The alleged confessions from Ms. Dalton in regards to the murder of Ms. May are solely based on Prosecutor's investigator Richard Cooksey repeating hearsay. There is no record of any confession coming directly from Kerry Dalton.[7]
Dalton accused Prosecutor Jeff Dusek, of purposeful misconduct. "The thing that makes me the most mad is that he is lying, and he knows he's lying," she said at the trial. The jury's foreman, John Castleman, said they based the verdict of death on "the type of murder it was", although there was no physical evidence to support the prosecution's story that there even was a murder.[8]
Depiction in media
Dalton's case was featured on the Discovery Channel series Deadly Women (Season 5, Episode 13, "Pleasure from Pain"), which first aired December 2, 2011. Her 1995 trial is also documented in a book, Cages, written and published by Dalton's sister in 2012.[6]
References
- Thorpe, Victoria Ann (2012-05-31). Cages. ISBN 978-0615644660.
- Chiang, Harriet (31 January 1998). "Women On California Death Row". San Francisco Chronicle. Retrieved 12 September 2012.
- http://kerrylyndalton.blogspot.com/2020/01/this-page-from-ca-supreme-court-opinion.html
- https://www.courts.ca.gov/opinions/documents/S046848.PDF
- Avila, David A. (16 May 1992). "Arraignments Postponed in Torture Murder". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 12 September 2012.
- Thorpe, Victoria Ann (2012). Cages. AnahataJourney. ISBN 978-0615644660.
- Krueger, Anne (October 28, 1992). "Hearing Told of Suspect's 'Violence' Boasts". The San Diego Union-Tribune.
- Wolf, Leslie (March 9, 1995). "Jury Recommends Death Penalty in 1988 Torture-slaying". The San Diego Union-Tribune.