Basil Osborne

Alfred Herbert Ernest Osborne, formerly known as Basil Osborne (born 12 April 1938), is a former Orthodox Christian bishop. Osborne was formerly an auxiliary bishop of the Patriarchate of Moscow from 1991 to 2006 and a titular bishop under the Ecumenical Patriarchate from 2006 to 2010. He was returned to lay status, at his own request, in February 2010 after indicating to the Holy Synod of the Patriarchate of Constantinople that he wished to resume a family life and be free to remarry (having formerly been married and widowed prior to his consecration as a bishop).[1][2][3]

Osborne held the position of Bishop of Sergievo as a bishop of the Russian Orthodox Church and the position of Bishop of Amphipolis within the Ecumenical Patriarchate, in which he served as an assistant bishop in its Patriarchal Exarchate for Orthodox Parishes of Russian Tradition in Western Europe, charged with the care of its people in Great Britain[4] and Ireland.

Biography

Osborne was born in Alexandria, Egypt, in 1938, but grew up in the United States. He was introduced to Orthodoxy in 1957 by Father Michael Gelsinger, Professor of Classics at the University at Buffalo, New York. Osborne married his wife, Rachel, in 1962, after a time of service in the US Army. He received his doctorate (in classics) from the University of Cincinnati, Ohio, in 1969. His wife died in 1991.[4][3]

Osborne was ordained to the diaconate by Metropolitan Anthony of Sourozh (Moscow Patriarchate) in 1969 and priest in 1973, serving the Russian Orthodox Parish of the Annunciation in Oxford. Following his wife's death in 1991 he was consecrated in 1993 as Bishop of Sergievo in the Moscow Patriarchate, to assist Metropolitan Anthony of Sourozh. Following Metropolitan Anthony's death in 2003, he was appointed temporary administrator of the Diocese of Sourozh, which position he held until 2006.[4][2]

Departure from the Russian Orthodox Church: 2006

In 2006, Osborne left the Patriarchate of Moscow and sought reception into the Ecumenical Patriarchate of Constantinople - a process which caused much controversy and ecclesiastical friction. After a lengthy dispute between the two patriarchates over the situation and the canonical questions raised by a bishop who seeks entry into a new jurisdiction without release from his current patriarchate, the situation was eventually resolved and Osborne was received into the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a titular bishop with the title of Bishop of Amphipolis.[5][6][2] As with all other titular bishops in the Ecumenical Patriarchate who do not have sees, he was technically known as one of the "bishops of the throne" (i.e. a bishop who serves the patriarchate in a titular manner, rather than being head of a diocese).

Osborne's reception into the Ecumenical Patriarchate came at the end of a period of intense controversy.[7] He was forcibly retired from his position as administrator of the Sourozh diocese after seeking incardination into the Ecumenical Patriarchate without receiving release from Moscow.[8] In a letter sent to the Patriarch of Moscow without notice to his clergy, Osborne requested that he and the whole of the Diocese of Sourozh (and not simply the members who wished to follow him) be released from the jurisdiction of the Moscow Patriarchate in order to be received into the jurisdiction of the Ecumenical Patriarch as a new diocese existing alongside Constantinople's Patriarchal Exarchate for Orthodox Parishes of Russian Tradition in Western Europe.[9] Without awaiting a full response from the Patriarchate of Moscow, he wrote to the Ecumenical Patriarch on 2 May 2006, again repeating his desire to establish a new diocese under Constantinople.[10] Announcement of Osborne's retirement by the Synod of Moscow followed upon his refusal to withdraw this letter to Constantinople. On 9 May 2006, Patriarch Alexy II issued a decree saying Osborne was relieved of his duties as administrator of the Diocese of Sourozh.[4] On 16 May 2006, Osborne appealed the decision to the Ecumenical Patriarchate on the basis of Canons 9 and 17 of the Fourth Ecumenical Council and also Canon 28 of the same council.[5][6] Such canons, some argue, endow the Constantinopolitan Patriarch with the privilege of the ekkliton (read, hearing appeal) and grant it jurisdiction over regions not already subject to the other four senior patriarchates, Rome, Alexandria, Antioch and Jerusalem. This interpretation of these canons is not undisputed and runs contrary to the classical interpretations of the canons found in the canonical commentaries of the Church.[lower-alpha 1]

Osborne's request to have himself and his diocese received into the Ecumenical Patriarchate as a new diocese was not granted by that body; however, the Ecumenical Patriarchate subsequently accepted him into its jurisdiction on the basis of his appeal which followed, although Moscow had not issued a canonical release and had instructed him not to be received into another patriarchate until matters could be looked into by an appropriate commission. Additionally, it requested his presence in person numerous times, which Osborne refused to heed on all occasions, instructing others to do likewise.[11] Given these circumstances, the Moscow Patriarchate did not regard his incardination into the Ecumenical Patriarchate as valid, nor did it recognise the title "Bishop of Amphipolis" given to him by the Holy Synod of the Patriarchate of Constantinople on 8 June 2006.[12] Considering him still a bishop of the Russian Orthodox Church, but in retirement, it referred to him in official correspondence without titular connection, as 'The Right Reverend Bishop Basil (Osborne)'.[13] Similarly, it did not regard as valid the 'letters of release' issued by Osborne to his former clergy in the Diocese of Sourozh - letters either backdated or prepared earlier, in early February.[14] Osborne was summoned to appear before the Moscow Patriarchate synod on 17 July[15] but declined to appear. From 19 July 2006 the Synod of the Moscow Patriarchate placed him under temporary suspension, forbidding him "from celebrating divine services until his repentance or until the decision of the matter by a court of bishops".[13][16]

The resolutions of the Moscow Patriarchate of 19 July 2006 therefore made Osborne's canonical stature a matter of intense dispute between Moscow and Constantinople. According to the Ecumenical Patriarchate, Osborne could legitimately celebrate as a bishop; according to Moscow, he was forbidden to do so. Accordingly, no communicant of the Moscow Patriarchate who wished to remain faithful to the decisions of his hierarchy could knowingly participate in a liturgy at which Osborne celebrated as a bishop, nor could they receive Holy Communion from him. Similarly, after these resolutions, no Moscow Patriarchate priest could concelebrate with Osborne.[8]

The patriarchates of Alexandria (19 June 2006)[17][18] and Jerusalem (June 6),[19][20] along with the Church of Cyprus (June 14)[21] and the Church of Albania (August 12)[22][23]—all of whom have close social, ecclesiastical and political ties to the Ecumenical Patriarchate—later confirmed their support of its authority to act in the manner that it had.[lower-alpha 2] The ruling archbishop of the Church of Greece publicly "deplored" Constantinople's decision to accept Osborne into its jurisdiction and in this context expressed regret at both "emerging threats to constructive co-operation between local ethnic diasporas" and "violations of Church order and troubles, harmful primarily to the unity of the Holy Orthodox Churches."[24]

In March 2007 negotiations took place in Geneva between representatives of the two patriarchates (Moscow and Constantinople). These concluded with the Holy Synod of the Moscow Patriarchate releasing Osborne from its jurisdiction on 27 March. Commenting to the media on the synod's decision, Metropolitan Kyrill of Smolensk and Kaliningrad, chairman of the Moscow Patriarchate's Department of External Church Relations, said that "The problem arose because Bishop Basil went over to Constantinople without any request from Constantinople and without any consent from the Moscow Patriarchate. Now Constantinople has requested his documents, which customarily include a letter of release. This means that the Moscow Patriarchate has granted Bishop Basil a canonical leave."[25][26]

In response to this, Osborne wrote:

"On Wednesday, 27 March 2007, the Holy Synod of the Patriarchate of Moscow decided to accede to the request of the Patriarchate of Constantinople and to forward my personal dossier to His Holiness Patriarch Bartholomew. This means that they have accepted the situation as it is, i.e. that I am a bishop in good standing within the Ecumenical Patriarchate and that from their point of view there is no longer any problem about their clergy celebrating with me or with the clergy under me. This is a welcome move - though one that could have been made many months ago. It restores normal relations between the Patriarchates and will make life easier for us all."[27]

Ecumenical Patriarchate: 2006–2009

As Bishop of Amphipolis, Osborne was appointed assistant bishop within the Ecumenical Patriarchate's Archdiocese of Parishes of the Russian Tradition in Western Europe (i.e. the 'Exarchate'), under the headship of Archbishop Gabriel of Komana. In his brief time as assistant bishop in the Exarchate, Basil's authority was over a newly formed vicariate of parishes in the British Isles who had followed him in his departure from the Russian Orthodox Church into the Ecumenical Patriarchate.[5][6] This body was given the title Episcopal Vicariate of Great Britain and Ireland, and consisted of some twelve parishes and some smaller Eucharistic Communities (details are disputed: these are enumerated and discussed here).[28] As part of this role, he sat on the council of the Exarchate.[5][6]

The Vicariate, as it existed under its vicar-bishop, was made up of a number of full-time parishes and some parishes and communities that meet less frequently. It was created by an act of the Council of the Archdiocese during an extraordinary meeting held on 9 June 2006, one day after the Holy Synod of the Patriarchate of Constantinople had met (8 June 2006) and issued a statement receiving Bishop Basil of Sergievo into the Patriarchate of Constantinople – an act that caused substantial controversy, as he had not been released from the Moscow Patriarchate.[29] The same statement gave Bishop Basil the new title, Bishop of Amphipolis (taken from an ancient see in Greece that no longer has a bishop), and charged him with the care of parishes in Great Britain and Ireland, as auxiliary bishop under Archbishop Gabriel of Komana in Paris.[30] At that time, no such parishes existed. After his appointment a number of parishes and communities, as well as some of the clergy and laity of the Diocese of Sourozh, followed Bishop Basil into the Archdiocese and came to constitute the Episcopal Vicariate. Other parishes and communities were formed later, where none had previously existed, for example in Cumbria, and Northampton.

Bishop Basil's first liturgical service as a member of the Archdiocese was a concelebration of the Divine Liturgy with Archbishop Gabriel in the Alexander Nevsky Cathedral in Paris on 18 June 2006. Statutes were adopted by the Episcopal Vicariate on 23 June 2007,[31] and the Vicariate was registered as a charity (registration number 1124252) on 29 May 2008.[32][33]

Retirement

In 2009, Osborne requested retirement and announced to his local clergy that he would retire at the end of November, giving as his own reasons his age and desire to spend more time with his family.

Bishop Basil announced his retirement in a letter to parishioners on 1 September 2009, stating in that letter that he intended to retire on 28 November 2009, the same day that the Archdiocesan Council would meet to, presumably, discuss the Vicariate's future.[34] However, when the Council met on 23 September 2009, under the presidency of Archbishop Gabriel, it moved Bishop Basil's retirement forward, to be effective from 12 October 2009.[1][35] In its communique No. 05-09 (dated 23 September), it noted that Bishop Basil "will not have any further pastoral, liturgical or administrative mission in the Vicariate" from his retirement. Archbishop Gabriel made clear that the life of the [Vicariate's] parishes and communities in Great Britain and Ireland "are continuing, and that new communities are in formation and the ordinations of new clerics in preparation."[1]

Osborne's retirement from active ecclesiastical office was accompanied by retirement as rector of the Parish of the Annunciation in Oxford. The episcopal vicariate that he had formerly headed was changed to the status of a deanery within the archdiocese.[36]

Return to lay status

In early 2010, Osborne petitioned the Patriarchate of Constantinople for a return to lay status "to enable him to have a family home with the possibility of marrying again".[3] This petition was granted, although the precise terms of the decree of the Holy Synod bringing about the return to lay status have not been published.[1] Osborne's approach to the Ecumenical Patriarch was effected, at his request, by his ruling archbishop, Gabriel of Comana. On 20 February 2010 Archbishop Gabriel informed members of his archdiocese that the decision to "return Bishop Basil to lay status" had been made the previous week.[1][2]

Notes

1. For a canonical commentary on this canon, see: Prerogatives of the Ecumenical Patriarchate. As an example of the variances in interpretation, regarding Canon 9 of Chalcedon, St Nicodemos of the Holy Mountain comments: "[This canon] did not say that if any clergyman has a dispute or difference with the Metropolitan of any diocese or parish whatever, they must be tried before the Bishop of Constantinople…." Zonaras likewise says that the Bishop of Constantinople is not necessarily entitled to sit as judge over all Metropolitans, but (only) over those who are judicially subject to him, and that "The Bishop of Constantinople must hear the appeals only of those who are subject to the Bishop of Constantinople, precisely as the Bishop of Rome must hear the appeals only of those who are subject to the Bishop of Rome." In D. Cummings, trans., The Rudder of the Orthodox Catholic Church: The Compilation of the Holy Canons Saints Nicodemus and Agapius, West Brookfield, MA: The Orthodox Christian Educational Society, 1983, p. 255.
2. Refer to ORDOs of the Ecumenical Patriarchate, the latest being that of 2006, for the official designation of titular bishops as "bishops/hierarchs" of the "Throne" and to the text of canons 9, 17 and 28 for the rights and privileges of Constantinople regarding extraterritorial appeals and jurisdiction in the "varvariki", regions beyond the borders of the other senior patriarchates.

References

1. "becomes Exarchate.org.uk | Exarchate.org.uk" (PDF). Exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2016-03-04. Retrieved 2011-03-02.
2. "Bishop Basil (Osborne) is defrocked and laicised | The Russian Orthodox Church". mospat.ru. 24 February 2010. Retrieved 2019-05-18.
3. "Former Russian bishop in Britain deprived of his office and monastic orders". www.interfax-religion.com. 24 February 2010. Retrieved 2019-05-18.
4. "Biography of Bishop Basil of Amphipolis". Archevêché des églises russes en Europe occidentale. Archived from the original on 2006-07-20. Retrieved 2019-05-18.
5. "Communiqué N° 12-06 of the Council of the Archdiocese". Archevêché des églises russes en Europe occidentale. Archived from the original on 2007-12-13. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
6. "Communiqué N° 12-06 of the Council of the Archdiocese". Archevêché des Églises Orthodoxes Russes en Europe Occidentale. 2006. Retrieved 18 May 2019.
7. Details and a chronological history here.
8. Abp. Innokenty of Korsun, temporary Administrator of the Diocese of Sourozh (23 July 2006). "To all the clergy and faithful of the Diocese of Sourozh". sourozh.org. Archived from the original on 2008-09-05. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
9. See Osborne's letter of 24 April 2006. On taking this decision without consulting his clergy or diocesan council, see his statements online
10. See the text of his brief letter to the Ecumenical Patriarchate. In this letter, unlike his original letter to the Moscow Patriarchate, he indicates that the new diocese would be made up of himself, "together with those clergy and parishes that wish to follow me."
11. As reported by the commission established to investigate the issue. This report also noted Osborne's use of the internet to propagate information on the disputes outside of official channels.
12. "Press Release for the election of Bishop Basil of Amphipolis". www.patriarchate.org. 8 June 2006. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
13. "Decision of the Holy Synod concerning Bishop Basil (Osborne) from the minutes of the meeting of the Holy Synod of the Russian Orthodox Church, chaired by His Holiness the Patriarch, 19th July, 2006". sourozh.org. Archived from the original on 2006-07-20. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
14. "Letter of Archbishop Innokenty of Korsun to the clergy of the Diocese of Sourozh 22 May 2006". sourozh.org. 22 May 2006. Archived from the original on 2008-04-06. Retrieved 2019-05-19. A few days ago it became known that His Grace, Bishop Basil, already having been retired, sent many of you decrees dated 1st February, 2006, according to which ‘you are released from all your responsibilities in the diocese’.
    In connection with this, I urge all of you not to let yourselves be disturbed by this but to carry on, as before, your work in the parishes which have been entrusted to you. A decree sent out by a bishop after his administrative authority has been ended has neither canonical nor juridical force.
15. "Russian Church: Bishop Basil Osborn's move to Constantinople's jurisdiction invalid as he is still her bishop". www.interfax-religion.com. 14 June 2006.
16. "No 103 (July 20, 2006) » Europaica Bulletin » OrthodoxEurope.org". orthodoxeurope.org. Retrieved 2019-06-19.
17. "Letter of Reply from His Most Godly Beatitude Patriarch Theodoros II of Alexandria to His All-Holiness the Most Godly Oecumenical Patriarch Vartholomaeos concerning the election of His Grace Bishop Basil of Amphipolis (dated 19th June 2006)". www.patriarchate.org. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
18. "Letter of Reply from His Most Godly Beatitude Patriarch Theodoros II of Alexandria to His All-Holiness the Most Godly Oecumenical Patriarch Vartholomaeos concerning the election of His Grace Bishop Basil of Amphipolis (dated 19th June 2006)". exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original on 2008-08-28. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
19. "Letter of Reply from His Most Godly Beatitude Patriarch Theophilos III of Jerusalem to His All-Holiness the Most Godly Oecumenical Patriarch Vartholomaeos concerning the election of His Grace Bishop Basil of Amphipolis (dated 9th June 2006)". www.patriarchate.org. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
20. "Letter of Reply from His Most Godly Beatitude Patriarch Theophilos III of Jerusalem to His All-Holiness the Most Godly Oecumenical Patriarch Vartholomaeos concerning the election of His Grace Bishop Basil of Amphipolis (dated 9th June 2006)". exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original on 2007-12-11. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
21. "Letter of Reply from His Eminence Metropolitan Chrysostomos of Paphos, Locum-tenens of the Archi-episcopal Throne of Cyprus, to His All-Holiness the Most Godly Oecumenical Patriarch Vartholomaeos concerning the election of His Grace Bishop Basil of Amphipolis (dated 14th June 2006)". www.patriarchate.org. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
22. "Circular Letter from the Primate of the Orthodox Church of Albania on the subject of the election of Bishop Basil, addressed to His All-Holiness the Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew II". exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original on 2008-04-09. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
23. "Ἀπαντητικόν Γράμμα τοῦ Μακ. Ἀρχιεπισκόπου Τιράνων καί πάσης Ἀλβανίας κ. Ἀναστασίου, πρός τήν Α.Θ.Παναγιότητα, τόν Οἰκουμενικόν Πατριάρχην κ.κ. Βαρθολομαῖον, περί τῆς ἐκλογῆς τοῦ Θεοφιλ. Ἐπισκόπου Ἀμφιπόλεως κ. Βασιλείου (12/08/2006)". www.patriarchate.org. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
24. "Constantinople's acceptance of Bishop Basil Osborn a threat to inter-Orthodox peace - Archbishop Christodoulos". www.interfax-religion.com. 31 January 2007. Retrieved 2019-05-18.
25. "Canonical conflict over Bishop Basil Osborn's going over to Constantinople settled - Metropolitan Kirill". www.interfax-religion.com. 29 March 2007. Retrieved 2019-05-18.
26. "Интерфакс-Религия: Урегулирован канонический конфликт вокруг перехода епископа Василия (Осборна) в Константинополь - митрополит Кирилл". www.interfax-religion.ru. 29 March 2007. Retrieved 2019-05-18.
27. "Archive of past news and events of interest for our parish". Episcopal Vicariate of Great Britain and Ireland | Orthodox Parish of the Annunciation. Archived from the original on 2008-05-14. Retrieved 2019-05-19.
28. "Parishes". exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original on 2007-11-07. Retrieved 2019-05-20.
29. See details under Russian Orthodox Diocese of Sourozh.
30. "Communiqué No 12-6 of the Council of the Archdiocese, meeting on 9 June 2006". dioceseinfo.org. Archived from the original on 2007-09-27. Retrieved 2014-08-15.
31. ":. Ктрк "Дэвком"" (PDF). Exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original (PDF) on 4 March 2016. Retrieved 17 September 2013.
32. "Home Page". exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original on 2008-10-11. Retrieved 2019-05-19. The Episcopal Vicariate is now a registered Charity! The number is 1124252. If you have made any donations to the Vicariate since 23 June 2007 and are a UK tax payer, and have not yet filled in a Gift Aid form, please download one here, and send to the Treasurer c/o the address on the form. Thank you! Questions? Please contact the treasurer direct by email here.
33. "Archdiocese Of Orthodox Parishes Of Russian Tradition In Western Europe-Exarchate Of The Ecumenical Patriarchate-Deanery Of Great Britain And Ireland". beta.charitycommission.gov.uk. Retrieved 2019-04-04.
34. "Former Russian Church Bishop in Britain who almost split the local diocese offers his resignation". Interfax-Religion. 11 September 2009. Retrieved 17 September 2013.
35. "Archevêché des églises russes en Europe occidentale - Communiqué N° 05-09 du Conseil de l'Archevêché". Exarchat.org. Archived from the original on 2011-07-26. Retrieved 2011-03-02.
36. "Home Page". exarchate-uk.org. Archived from the original on 2010-04-28. Retrieved 2019-05-19. Following the retirement of Bishop Basil of Amphipolis as head of the Vicariate of Great Britain and Ireland, the parishes and communities now constitute a deanery directly under the omophorion of Archbishop Gabriel of Comana.

External links

• Episcopal Vicariate of Great Britain and Ireland
• Biography on the Exarchate's homepage (dead link). Archived July 20, 2006, at the Wayback Machine
• The Statement of the Holy Synod of the Russian Orthodox Church concerning the decision of the Holy Synod of the Patriarchate of Constantinople on receiving Bishop Basil (Osborne) into its jurisdiction, 19 July 2006.