Alan Young (lawyer)

Alan N. Young is Professor Emeritus of law at Osgoode Hall Law School in Toronto, Ontario, Canada. Young retired July, 2018. Prior to starting his teaching career at Osgoode in 1986, Young clerked for Chief Justice Bora Laskin of the Supreme Court of Canada and worked as a criminal lawyer in Toronto.

Alan N. Young
Law Professor/Lawyer
Personal details
NationalityCanadian
EducationYork University
OccupationProfessor / Lawyer / Researcher
Known forInnocence Project
Websitehttp://www.osgoode.yorku.ca/faculty-and-staff/young-alan-n/

Young is the co-founder and former director of Osgoode's Innocence Project, which seeks to investigate and overturn cases of wrongful conviction and provides experiential education to law students.[1] Young has been recognized by Canadian Lawyer Magazine as one of the "Top 25 Most Influential" in the justice system and legal profession in 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2014.[2] In 2018, Young was also awarded the Dianne Martin Medal for Social Justice Through Law.

Early life and education

Young grew up in a middle-class Toronto home in the Jewish neighbourhood of Bathurst and Wilson until the age of 10 and attended Associated Hebrew Day School. Young attended school at York's Osgoode Hall Law School, ranking at the top of his class. He also won a total of seven academic awards during his time at law school. He then clerked for former Supreme Court of Canada Chief of Justice, Bora Laskin, in 1981. He then obtained his LLM at Harvard Law. In 1986, Young was hired as an Associate Professor by Osgoode Hall Law School, York University Keele Campus in Toronto.

An avid writer since childhood, between 1998 and 2006, Young wrote regular columns in the Toronto Star and Now Magazine, covering controversial topics such as racial profiling, liability of public officials, and legal protection of alternative lifestyles.

Challenging state authority

As a young law professor, Young commenced a series of challenges to state authority in the late 1980s. In 1989, Young was writing an article for the Media and Communications Law Journal on a recent decision by a court in Florida to ban the sale of a rap record called "As Nasty as They Wanna Be", and while writing this article, a bookseller in London, Ontario, Mark Emery, was charged for selling this record. With extensive research having been completed for the article, Young offered to assist the bookseller on a pro bono basis by launching a constitutional challenge to the obscenity law and a challenge to the manner in which expressive materials are seized prior to trial.[3]

The challenge was not successful, but, this case began a 25-year journey of offering pro bono legal assistance to vulnerable people seeking to challenge state authority. The wide variety of challenges and cases Young has brought can be organized around six thematic categories:

Constitutional challenges to the Criminal Code

After the unsuccessful obscenity challenge in 1991, Young was also then unsuccessful in challenging the gambling offences in 1993.[4] However, he was successful in striking down the drug literature prohibition under s.462.2 of the Criminal Code in 1995.[5] He also unsuccessfully challenged the drug paraphernalia prohibition contained in the same section in four different jurisdictions and two provinces.[6]

In 1997, Young launched a constitutional challenge to the offence of marijuana possession, which was ultimately dismissed by the Supreme Court of Canada.[7] However, although the law was upheld, Young created two significant exemptions to the marijuana laws. In 1996, he secured the first licence for a farmer to grow cannabis for industrial purposes (i.e. industrial hemp),[8] and, more significantly, in a series of court cases from 1998 to 2006, he established the right of patients to use cannabis for medical purposes.[9] These cases compelled the government to enact a medical program and to establish a supply of medical cannabis. In addition, due to the inadequacies of the medical program, Young was able to secure court rulings requiring the government to amend its regulatory provisions on two occasions [10]

Perhaps one of the most celebrated victories of Young's career is the case of R v Bedford (2013), in which he, and a team of students, successfully challenged three provisions of Canada's sex work laws.[11] As a result of this successful invalidation, Parliament enacted a new legislative regime governing prostitution. Despite the success of the court case, Young was very disappointed with the Harper government's amendments to the Criminal Code, and in an interview with CBC, he stated that:

In 2014, the government... was given the chance to make history, but instead, chose to repeat the mistakes of history...The government has created a regime which will hurt communities, and is contrary to public interest, as it will push sex workers back into dangerous street forums.[12]

Furthermore, in an article written by Kirk Makin for Canadian Lawyer Magazine, Young's long, dedicated and difficult time defending sex workers was aptly summarized:

'It was sad and pathetic,' he recalls. 'I couldn't see the public interest behind the raid. It was just hurting people and wasting court and police time.' The message Young took away would dictate the shape of his nascent career: the state has no business interfering with consensual, pleasure-seeking acts.[13]

Freedom of expression

Beyond the obscenity and drug literature cases, Young has also championed numerous free speech issues, including the right of aggrieved patients to picket on hospital property and the right of journalists to protect their sources.[14] He was also retained to represent the interests of the art galleries with respect to the operation and impact of child pornography laws.[15]

Young also exercised his free speech rights by writing biweekly newspaper columns for the Toronto Star and for Now Magazine between the years of 2002 and 2006. His first column for the Toronto Star triggered a great deal of hate mail from monarchists ("Queen is Hardly a Victim", Toronto Star, June 23, 2002) and his first column for Now Magazine resulted in the police issuing a libel notice ("Sliding Scales", Now Magazine, November 20, 2003).[16] Continuing on this path of stirring up debate, Young published a critique of the legal profession in 2003 in a book called "Justice Defiled: Perverts, Pot Heads, Serial Killers and Lawyers." [17] In the preface to the book, he noted that he chose to write an offensive book as a form of "professional suicide note," as he wanted to expose all the blemishes and warts of the profession.

Helping individuals with mental disorders

Over the past 25 years, Young has assisted dozens of individuals suffering from mental disorders resolve emerging conflicts with family members and state officials. More specifically, he has assisted in preventing child apprehension proceedings from being commenced, in obtaining social assistance and disability benefits, in challenging involuntary committal to psychiatric hospitals in mediating family conflicts and in securing treatment options for paranoid schizophrenics to prevent the laying of criminal charges for minor offences. Most of this work was done to prevent the escalation of conflict into legal proceedings; however, Young has also represented the interests of the mentally disordered in university discipline proceedings and police discipline proceedings.

One case that aptly summarizes Young's dedication to assisting those with mental disorders is R v Taylor.[18] In 1992, he was appointed as amicus curiae by the Ontario Court of Appeal to assist a mentally-disordered appellant who was self-represented. As a result of this case, significant changes were made to operating test used by courts to determine when an individual is unfit to stand trial and with this test, there is greater due process protections for the trial rights of disordered accused persons.

Helping the incarcerated and the wrongfully convicted

As director of the Innocence Project, Young has worked on dozens of cases involving claims of wrongful conviction. In addition to investigating these claims, Young is often required to assist these incarcerated individuals with a variety of issues relating to the conditions of their incarceration and their relationships with friends and family on the outside. Over the years, he has conducted numerous parole hearings, two applications to transfer Canadians from prisons in Thailand and the securing of the right of a federal inmate to complete his university degree online.

In the context of working on claims of wrongful convictions, Young has continued to use litigation as a tool for political change. More specifically, he has brought a number of applications to establish a constitutional duty to preserve evidence and to disclose evidence in a post-conviction setting.[19] In 2019, Young successfully established a right of post-conviction disclosure for wrongful conviction claimants who are seeking information and materials found in government files. [20]

In 2015, Young was appointed amicus curiae by the Nova Scotia Court of Appeal to assist incarcerated individual who wished to challenge the terms and conditions of their imprisonment through the writ of habeas corpus.[21] This case resulted in an expansion of the jurisdictional scope of the writ.

Challenging state officials

In an effort to increase the accountability of public officials, Young has assisted numerous individuals who sought to launch complaints against police officers, prosecutors and their own lawyers.[22] In particular, he has on three occasions initiated complaints against police officers with respect to the manner in which the police investigated, or failed to investigate, the death of a family member.[23] He has also assisted two self-represented individuals successfully sue the police for malicious prosecution.[24]

Victim rights

Notwithstanding his institutional role as a defense lawyer, Young has also been a champion of the rights of crime victims for more than 20 years. He has been the primary consultant for the federal Department of Justice on the issue of victims' rights since the 1990s, and has represented numerous victims' rights groups seeking legislative reform.[25] He has also assisted numerous crime victims seeking information from police and prosecutors on the status of their cases, and has attended court as a support person for many victims. Moreover, in 1999, he commenced an application seeking to create constitutional protections for crime victims under Section 7 of the Charter, but the application was not successful.[26]

Media and communications

For the past 25 years, Young has been a regular guest on numerous television and radio networks, as well as appeared in many documentaries. His work has been profiled on programs such as CP24's "Legal Briefs", CTV's "Canada AM", "W5", and "The Verdict", and TVO's "Studio 2." [27] Moreover, there have been several print articles written about Young's contributions to the legal profession.[28]

In 2003, Young was recognized by Now Magazine in their annual Best of Toronto Awards, and as Freedom Fighter of the Month by High Times Magazine.

On two occasions, Young has spoken at the annual Ideacity Conference, hosted by Moses Znaimer. The issues which he has discussed at this conference include that of wrongful conviction as well as the legalization of marijuana.[29]

On September 25, 2018, TVO aired an interview with Young on "The Agenda with Steve Paikin" about his recent retirement.[30] This interview focused on Young's career in criminal law as well as his academic career as a Professor of Law at Osgoode Hall Law School.

Books

Justice Defiled: Perverts, Potheads, Serial Killers & Lawyers, published 2003 by Key Porter Books. ISBN 1-55263-225-3 [31]

References
  1. "Archived copy". Archived from the original on 2016-04-28. Retrieved 2016-09-19.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
  2. "The Top 25 Most Influential 2014".
  3. R v Emery, [1992] OJ No 640 (OCJ Gen. Div.)
  4. R v Andriopoulous, [1994] OJ No 2314 (CA)
  5. Iorfida v MacIntyre, [1994] OJ No 2293 (OCJ Gen. Div.)
  6. See, for example, R v Spindloe, [2001] SJ No 266 (SKCA)
  7. R v Malmo-Levine; R v Clay, [2002] SCJ No 88 (SCC)
  8. Interview with Young, April 18, 2018.
  9. Wakeford v Canada, [2001] OJ No 4921 (CA), affirming the decision in [2001] OJ No 390 (SCJ); Hitzig et al v Canada, [2003] OJ No 3873 (CA); and Sfetkopoulous v Canada, [2008] FCJ No 1472 (FCA)
  10. Hitzig v Canada (2003) 177 CCC 3(d) 449 (OCA); Sfetkopoulos v Canada (2008) FCA 328
  11. Canada (Attorney General) v Bedford, [2013] 3 SCR 1101 (SCC)
  12. Kady O'Malley, "'Confused' prostitution bill can't be fixed, lawyer Alan Young says," CBC News (17 September 2014), online: <www.cbc.ca/news>.
  13. Kirk Makin, "Bad law," Canadian Lawyer Magazine (5 May 2014), online: <www.canadianlawyermag.com>.
  14. Interview with Young, 18 April 2018. In the late 1990s, Young championed the rights of medical marijuana advocate, Terry Parker, to picket outside of Sick Kids Hospital to express concerns about non-consensual psychosurgery. In the early 2000s, he championed the rights of journalist, Stephen Williams (author of Invisible Darkness), to protect his sources of information.
  15. Attorney General (Ontario) v Langer, [1995] OJ No 1045 (OCJ Gen. Div.)
  16. Interview with Young, supra Note 15.
  17. Alan Young, Justice Defiled: Perverts, Potheads, Serial Killers and Lawyers (Toronto: Key Porter Books, 2013).
  18. [1992] OJ No 2394 (CA)
  19. See, for example, Chaudhary v Ontario (Attorney General), [2013] OJ No 4616 (CA)
  20. Albon v Ontario (Attorney General), 2019 ONSC 3372
  21. Richards v Springhill Institution, [2015] NSJ No 178 (NSCA)
  22. See, for example, Green v Toronto (City) Police Service, [2016] OJ No 5877 (SCJ)
  23. See, for example, Brett Popplewell, "Police complaint system still flawed: critics," Toronto Star (3 August 2008), online: <www.thestar.com>.
  24. Oniel v Toronto (Metropolitan) Police Force, [2001] OJ No 90 (CA); McTaggart v Ontario, [2000] OJ No 4766 (SCJ).
  25. Alan Young, "The Role of the Victim in the Criminal Process: A Literature Review – 1989 to 1999" (Ottawa: Department of Justice – Research and Statistics Division, 2001); Alan Young, "Criminal Compensation in Canada: A Status Report" (Ottawa: Department of Justice, 2001); Alan Young, "Crime Victims and Constitutional Rights" (Ottawa: Department of Justice, 2003).
  26. Vanscoy v Ontario, [1999] OJ No 1661 (SCJ)
  27. For a selection of interviews and documentaries relating to Professor Young, please refer to the YouTube page "Alan Young Law Professor": https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCbTrdpWVsE1SPZbPMr1AvQA
  28. See, for example, David Silverberg, "Underground Culture Hails Young's Career," Canadian Jewish News (17 November 2003); Preston Peet, "Freedom Fighter of the Month: Alan Young," High Times (July 2003); Jim Coyle, "A Breath of Fresh Air in Pot Debate," Toronto Star (11 September 2001); Jeannie Marshall, "Keeping Private Lives Private," Ottawa Citizen (12 August 1998).
  29. Alan Young, The Innocence Project (Toronto: Ideacity, June 2014), online: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dn89NhACYEA>; Alan Young, Defending Pot (Toronto: Ideacity, June 2016), online: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W1murtA_bww>.
  30. "A Legal Disruptor".
  31. Justice Defiled, supra Note 18.
This article is issued from Wikipedia. The text is licensed under Creative Commons - Attribution - Sharealike. Additional terms may apply for the media files.